See More on Facebook

Analysis

Jinnah portrait row: Another example of India’s growing intolerance?

Hindu nationalists want Mohammed Ali Jinnah’s portrait taken off wall of prestigious Muslim campus.


Written by

Updated: May 8, 2018

Decades after the portrait of Mohammed Ali Jinnah, the founder of Pakistan, was hung at the campus of India’s prestigious Aligarh Muslim University (AMU), Hindu nationalists want it removed.

Jinnah, then a leader of distinction in undivided India, is now revered as Qaid-e-Azam or the Father of Pakistan. India and Pakistan have gone to war twice since the Partition of India in 1947, and their relations are anything but cordial.

Jinnah, Pakistan’s first governor-general, is counted among leaders who wanted a separate nation for Muslims. However, he is also counted among the most secular leaders of the subcontinent and many lament that Pakistan has failed to live up to his ideals with its divisive politics and its mistreatment of religious and ethnic minorities.

In a speech made on August 11, 1947, Jinnah famously remarked: “You are free; you are free to go to your temples, you are free to go to your mosques or to any other place of worship in the State of Pakistan. You may belong to any religion or caste or creed that has nothing to do with the business of the state.”

AMU was founded by Sir Syed Ahmed Khan, whose portraits also adorn several distinguished walls across India and abroad. Khan played a crucial role in educating millions of Muslims, especially women.

Since the controversy erupted last week, Khan’s portrait has gone missing from a government office in the northern state of Uttar Pradesh.

Hindu nationalists want both Jinnah’s and Khan’s portraits replaced by those of Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Adityanath Yogi, media reports said. During Modi’s reign as chief minister in the western India of Gujarat, pogroms left hundreds of Muslims dead.

Yogi was handpicked by Modi to lead Uttar Pradesh and his anti-Muslim posturing is no secret.

Strangely, the Bharatiya Janata Party’s (BJP) own senior leaders have praised Jinnah, time and again, as senior journalist Karan Thapar wrote in a piece for The Tribune.

During his visit to Jinnah’s mausoleum in Karachi in 2005, veteran BJP leader LK Advani wrote in the visitor’s book: “There are many people who leave an inerasable stamp on history but there are very few who actually create history. Qaid-e-Azam Mohammed Ali Jinnah was one such rare individual…”

Jaswant Singh, another senior BJP leader and a former foreign minister, defended Jinnah during the launch of his book “Jinnah-India, Partition, Independence” in 2009. He said India had misunderstood Jinnah and made a demon out of him and that even Mahatma Gandhi, considered by India as its Father of Nation, called him a “great man”.

Jinnah, also a leading barrister of his time, was offered a life membership by the students union of Aligarh Muslim University in 1938, and his portrait has been on the campus wall since.

The controversy over his portrait erupted when Satish Gautam, the BJP’s Member of Parliament from Aligarh, wrote to the university on May 1, asking why the portrait was on display. Since then the Hindu Yuva Vahini, founded by Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath, and ABVP, the student wing of the RSS, are making sure that the controversy does not die down.

Members of the Hindu Yuva Vahini barged into the varsity last week, shouting slogans and clashed with students, with Yogi Adityanath himself joining in the chorus for the portrait to be removed.

Exams have been postponed in the university, internet services disrupted, and section 144 of the Criminal Procedure Code, banning gatherings of more than four people, clamped on the campus. The varsity has become a cantonment with deployment of large contingents of paramilitary forces and police.

Many have reasoned that the Hindu right has more in common with Jinnah than the students at AMU and Indian Muslims, who chose to stay back in India and do not celebrate Jinnah as an icon. Though Jinnah was not alone in propounding the two-nation theory on the verge of India’s Partition, he is often blamed for the creation of Pakistan – something that dilutes his otherwise secular principles.

The current turmoil on the campus is not new, since this is a university favoured by Muslims, it is often targeted, and most controversies acquire a communal colour just as soon. The students at AMU are demanding “azaadi (freedom) from RSS”, India’s right-wing Hindu nationalist group, and see RSS’ demand as an attack on India’s notion of democracy.

India is becoming increasingly intolerant towards dissent, more so for its minorities. A Muslim was lynched on the suspicion of storing beef in his refrigerator. Cows are considered sacred in the country.

The main Opposition Congress party has accused the BJP of provoking sentiments and communalising the atmosphere with its “dirty politics of sensationalism, divisiveness, polarisation”.

While various reports claim that Jinnah’s photograph also adorns the walls of the Indian Institute of Advanced Studies in Shimla and the Bombay High Court in Mumbai, the AMU administration has asked the government to frame a policy on how institutions should deal with pictures of, or references to, controversial personalities such as Jinnah.



Enjoyed this story? Share it.


Lamat R Hasan
About the Author: Lamat is an Associate Editor at Asia News Network.

Eastern Briefings

All you need to know about Asia


Our Eastern Briefings Newsletter presents curated stories from 22 Asian newspapers from South, Southeast and Northeast Asia.

Sign up and stay updated with the latest news.



By providing us with your email address, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.

View Today's Newsletter Here

Analysis

Thai seafood giant to address slavery issues at UN

Thailand’s progress in promoting human rights in the fishing industry will be addressed in a panel session on modern slavery and human trafficking at the United Nations General Assembly by seafood giants Thai Union. Darian McBain, global director of sustainability for the Thai Union Group, will address the panel on the topic of “Stepping up Action to End Forced Labour, Modern Slavery and Human Trafficking”. “Thailand has made a number of advances on human rights, which should be commended, but there is more work to be done and I believe Thailand has the opportunity b


By The Nation (Thailand)
September 24, 2018

Analysis

Opinion: One Belt, One Road: We must secure our interest

Shah Husain Imam argues in the Daily Star that Bangladesh must put its interests first in joining China’s One Belt, One Road initiative. The ancient Silk Road, of which the Belt and Road Initiative is a gigantic new avatar, dates back to the Chinese Han Dynasty’s westward expansion more than 2100 years ago. The Road derived its name from the lucrative silk trade along the routes through which it branched into what are today the central Asian countries Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, Turkmenistan, Afghanistan, as well as present-day Pakistan and India to the south. These routes eventually spanned 4,000 miles to Europe. Interestingly, silk was regarded as more precious than gold as a commodity in those times as if to convey the misty romanticism with the old world charm about a fine fabric. At any rate, the Silk Road by no means offered silken smooth passage to travellers like Marco P


By Daily Star
September 21, 2018

Analysis

The aftermath of super-Typhoon Mangkhut

Typhoon Mangkhut, which swept through the Philippines, Hong Kong and Southern China over the weekend will go down on history as one of the regions most powerful storms in years. The Philippines In the Philippines, the aftermath of the storm which locally bore the name “Ompong” has been devastating. More than half a million people have been impacted and the latest death toll shows that the typhoon claimed the lives of at least 74 people and injured 74 more. As many as 55 people are still missing. The majority of those casualties are related to the dozens of landslides that tore through the Cordillera Administrative Region, a gold-mining zone. The search effort for those who are still missing has been slow-going. Major roads were rendered impassable, making heavy e


By Quinn Libson
September 19, 2018

Analysis

How a new party trumped the ruling PDP in Bhutan’s primary polls

In its third election as a full-fledged democracy, Bhutanese came out in large numbers to oust the ruling People’s Democratic Party run by Harvard-educated Tshering Tobgay. Come October 18 and Bhutan will witness a close fight between one of its oldest political parties – Druk Phuensum Tshogpa (DPT) – and Druk Nyamrup Tshogpa (DNT), a new party that has gained popularity in the recent past. The tiny Himalayan kingdom – called Druk Yul in Bhutanese (Land of the Thunder Dragon) – is nestled between economic rivals China and India. It opened up to the world as late as the 1970s. Before Bhutan became a two-party parliamentary democracy in March 2008, the Wangchuck hereditary monarchy wielded power from 1907. On September 15, Bhutanese


By Lamat R Hasan
September 19, 2018

Analysis

China hits back with tariffs on US$60b of US goods in trade war

China has hit back with reciprocal tariffs after President Trump imposed tariffs on over $200 billion of Chinese goods. China will impose tariffs on US$60 billion (S$82.3 billion) worth of US goods as retaliati


By The Straits Times
September 19, 2018

Analysis

Kim, Trump and the nuclear crisis: A conundrum eternal?

Kim should seize the opportunity to end nuclear crisis, engage with the world, writes Chon Shi-yong. This week (Tuesday, September 18) the South Korean President Moon Jae-in flies to Pyongyang to meet North Korean leader Kim Jong-un. The United States and North Korea are working to set up a second meeting between US President Donald Trump and Kim. These developments certainly raise hopes for a reinvigoration of negotiations on denuclearizing the North, which were propelled forward by the summits involving the three leaders held in quick succession earlier this year. But optimism should be guarded. A solution to the nuclear crisis, which has threatened security and stability in the region persistently for a quarter of a century, will not come soon and easily. The history — including what has happened in the short months before and after the historic Trump-Kim meeting in Singapore in June — tells you why th


By Asia News Network
September 17, 2018