See More on Facebook

Analysis, Economics

India’s tryst with the goods and services tax

At the stroke of midnight on June 30, 2017, Prime Minister Narendra Modi rolled out India’s biggest and most complex tax reform – a look back on its pluses and minuses.


Written by

Updated: July 3, 2018

India rolled out its biggest tax reform since 1947 – the year it got rid of the British Raj – a year ago on July 1, 2017.

The Goods and Services Tax (GST) had been a long time coming – 13 years to be precise – and was touted as the most significant economic reform unleashed by Narendra Modi after taking over as Prime Minister in 2014.

GST, in its simplest avatar, is a one-tax system for a large country with a population of more than 1 billion. It aims to tidy up the tedious taxation system – with its many layers of comprehensible and incomprehensible cesses and surcharges. However, as most Indians have learned the hard way over the year, GST is not quite the simplistic one-tax system as it was made out to be, but a rather complex tax reform.

A look back at a year of the biggest tax reform and the minuses seem to outweigh the plusses. Two of the biggest takeaways from the new GST regime – the number of registered tax payers has risen phenomenally and tax collections have shot up.

This apart from the obvious benefits such as the elimination of multiple taxes, decreasing prices which have helped the poor and middle classes, increasing transparency and therefore reduction of corruption, and, according to some observers, increased productivity.

However, the failures have been far more – mostly as the reforms were overwhelming and the IT system – the goods and services tax network (GSTN) portal – was ill-equipped to support the process.

A year later, almost everyone is in agreement that India cannot have a single rate GST. The six GST slabs – 0%, 3%, 5%, 12%, 18% and 28% – have compounded the woes of taxpayers. Refunds are delayed and a return filing system is not in place yet.

Within a year too many changes have been introduced – some for the benefit of taxpayers – yet all this has added to the confusion. According to a report, there have been more than 400 notifications, 100 circulars and FAQs issued so far. Products and services have been moved from one tax bucket to another, the list under 28% tax bracket has been drastically cut, the refund filing mechanism, the due dates and forms have been changed several times.

And there is talk of more changes in the future.

The Background

When the GST was endorsed by Parliament in 2016, it was hailed as a great move to make India a truly single market. However, two years on, businessmen are still nervous, and the government in an overdrive to defend and fix apparent loopholes.

Prime Minister Modi has had to deal with bad press all along. Reams have been written zeroing in on the flaws of GST with many claiming the smooth implementation of the new tax regime can only be a miracle.

So will GST – the mother of all taxes – help India, a US$2 trillion economy, one of Asia’s biggest, become a truly single market?

India’s 29 states and seven federally administered union territories had a different tax policy before the GST was rolled out. Theoretically speaking, all of these states and territories were covered by a common taxation system. However, bringing them all under a single tax umbrella – a change the Modi government describes as “transformational” – is far from easy.

There are problems aplenty with the taxation system. The prime one being more politicians, than tax experts, are the masterminds behind the mammoth project. Even before the taxes were unveiled the government was forced to abandon its original plan and agree to exclude high revenue tax products from the GST basket – crude oil, natural gas, aviation fuel, diesel and petrol – for the initial years, as the states were unwilling to give up their taxation powers.

After waxing eloquent of “the states and Centre pooling their powers and sovereignty”, the then finance minister, Arun Jaitley, spoke about the long-term benefits – a stark reminder of the times when high-value bank notes were scrapped in November 2016 and the government told citizens to focus on the future benefits.

Around 160 countries in the world have some form of GST or value added tax. However, unlike other countries where GST translates as one country, one tax, India has six slabs to tax goods and services ranging from zero to 28 per cent, with most commodities falling between 12 and 18 per cent. Luxurious products such as cosmetics are taxed the highest – at 28 per cent.

While GST replaced the heady concoction of national and local levies and duties, initially businesses had to file returns three times a month and 37 times annually. Reason enough to give businessmen a headache. And reason enough to make tax consultants and tax lawyers smile – perhaps the only ones smiling in these taxing times.



Enjoyed this story? Share it.


Lamat R Hasan
About the Author: Lamat is an Associate Editor at Asia News Network.

Eastern Briefings

All you need to know about Asia


Our Eastern Briefings Newsletter presents curated stories from 22 Asian newspapers from South, Southeast and Northeast Asia.

Sign up and stay updated with the latest news.



By providing us with your email address, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.

View Today's Newsletter Here

Analysis, Economics

What does Vietnam’s new cyber law mean for online dissent?

Will Facebook kowtow to the Vietnamese government to keep its market share. Facebook is in violation of a Vietnamese new cybersecurity law by allowing its users to post content critical of the communist government on its platform, the Ministry of Information and Communication announced on Wednesday of last week. The news came just days after the law went into effect on Jan. 1. The new legislation requires internet companies to comply with government demands to remove user-posted material it doesn’t like. The law also stipulates that information technology companies—Facebook and Google for instance—may be required to set up local offices and store customer data domestically, a feature which human rights advocates worry might make it easier for the government to track and charge dissidents for their online activities. This new legislation follows a pattern of increasing digital scrutiny by th


By Quinn Libson
January 15, 2019

Analysis, Economics

Seat belt warning as storm clouds loom in 2019

A look at potential headlines in 2019 by the Straits Times’ Warren Fernandez. You have been here before. As you settle into your comfortable seat for the long flight ahead, a voice crackles from the cockpit. “Our flying time today will be 12 hours, 40 minutes, and we expect a smooth journey ahead, but there looks to be some pockets of turbulence along the way,” your captain says, sounding vaguely assuring. “We suggest you keep your seat-belt on.” So was said on my recent Singapore Airlines flight home from holidaying abroad. It prompted several hours of meandering musings from 30,000 feet in the air about what lies ahead in the New Year. Some of the storm clouds that appear to loom on the political horizon include: 1. US-China: rivalries among frenemies Three recent developments sum up the precarious state of relations between the world’s two main powers, now on a tentative


By The Straits Times
January 7, 2019

Analysis, Economics

Pakistan seals financial assistance from UAE

$3 billion financial assistance sealed as Abu Dhabi Crown Prince meets Imran Khan in Islamabad. Pakistani and United Arab Emirates leadership have met thrice now in three months. Prime Minister Imran Khan visited the UAE twice after assuming office in August to seek economic assistance. Both countries last week finalised the terms and conditions of a $6.2 billion support package for Islamabad to help address its balance-of-payments crisis. A joint statement issued after the UAE royal’s visit said Prime Minister Khan thanked the crown prince for the “generous” balance-of-payments support of $3 billion, which appears to have materialised first out of the total financial package. Crown Prince Sheikh Mohammed bin Zayed, who last visited


By Dawn
January 7, 2019

Analysis, Economics

Afghan war helped Pakistan keep nuclear option: US papers

US backing for anti-Soviet fighters in Afghanistan may have enabled the Pakistan bomb. Torn between preventing Pakistan from going nuclear and fighting the Soviets in Afghanistan, the United States appears to have decided that pushing the Russians out of Kabul was more important, shows a set of documents released by the US State Department. Official US memos and letter — released under an arrangement to make public official documents after 30 years — show that Chinese leader Deng Xiaoping (in office from 1978 to 1989) also played a key role in convincing Washington to continue to support Islamabad despite its nuclear programme. Timeline: History of US-Pakistan relations A confidential State Department report, dated Aug 20, 1984, shows that by 1984 Washington knew Islamabad had acquired the


By Dawn
December 24, 2018

Analysis, Economics

What caused the Sunda Strait tsunami?

A volcanic eruption may have been the cause of the cataclysmic event. Questions still abound about what caused the tsunami that hit beaches in Lampung and Banten on Saturday night, killing at least 168 and injuring 750. The lack of a powerful earthquake or strong volcanic eruption caused the Meteorology, Climatology and Geophysics Agency (BMKG) to initially announce that the waves did not constitute a tsunami but were instead caused by high tide. “The BMKG has not recorded any earthquake occurring tonight. What happened in Anyer [Banten] and the surrounding area was not a tsunami, but a tidal wave. There is also a full moon tonight, which causes high tidal waves. Stay calm,” the BMKG stated on its Twitter account on Saturday night, in a tweet that has since been deleted. It was only discovered hours later that the tide was three meter high, and potentially caused by volcanic activity of Mou


By The Jakarta Post
December 24, 2018

Analysis, Economics

AIIB approves applications of six more countries

The total of countries with a membership in the China-led bank now stands at 93. The Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank (AIIB) announced on Wednesday that its Board of Governors has approved the membership applications of six more countries, bringing AIIB’s total approved members to 93. The new group of approved members is comprised of Algeria, Ghana, Libya, Morocco, Serbia and Togo. “Within three years, AIIB’s membership has increased from the 57 founders to 93 approved members from almost every continent. This shows our member’s commitment to multilateral cooperation and strengthens AIIB’s role in the international financial community,” said AIIB Vice President and Corporate Secretary Sir Danny Alexander. “The growing membership of the Bank in Europe and Africa also reflects the importance for growth and development of inter-regional connectivity, esp


By China Daily
December 21, 2018