See More on Facebook

Curiosity

Why India’s Partition continues to haunt the Kashmir Valley

Pakistani writer Anam Zakaria travels through Pakistan-administered Kashmir to hear its people – their sufferings, hopes and aspirations.


Written by

Updated: September 13, 2018

When the Indian subcontinent was partitioned more than 70 years ago, Jammu and Kashmir was split between India and newly created Pakistan. Both countries continue to administer parts of Kashmir, both claiming rights over the entire territory, both being haunted by the decades of violence that has consumed them.

There have been demands in Indian-administered Kashmir, with a predominantly Muslim population, to either merge with Pakistan or to create an independent country. The demand has been rejected by the Indian government amid violence and the killing of around 70,000 people since the late 1980s.

The Pakistani side of Kashmir has seen its share of violence and suffering. Pakistan-administered Kashmir was until over a decade ago described as one of the most closed-off territories of the world.

Pakistani writer Anam Zakaria travelled through Pakistan-administered Kashmir to hear its people – their sufferings, hopes and aspirations, breaking the silence surrounding a people who are often ignored in discussions on the present and future of Jammu and Kashmir even though they are important stakeholders in what happens in the region.

Zakaria’s journeys have culminated in “Between The Great Divide: A journey into Pakistan-administered Kashmir”. The book is being described by Indians and Pakistanis as not only a first but also a deeply empathic account of disrupted lives in the region.

Zakaria, a development professional, educationist and researcher based in Pakistan, speaks to Asia News Network about her book.

What made you look at Azad Kashmir?

I first visited Azad Kashmir as a tourist several years after the 2003 ceasefire had brought relative peace to the region. Until then I had imagined the ramifications of the Kashmir dispute to only be limited to the ‘other side’ of Kashmir. It was as I travelled through parts of Azad Kashmir and conversed with its people that I learnt how the larger conflict had impacted them – refugee camps, heavy mortar shelling, a constant state of vulnerability living by the volatile Line of Control (LoC), the threat of escalation of conflict, and so much more. I realised how important it was to explore the conflict from Azad Kashmir’s lens for a broader understanding of the Kashmir dispute and its implications.

How would you explain the Kashmir conflict to a pan-Asian audience?

Kashmir’s history, like its geography, has unfortunately become increasingly contested over the years. Narratives of the conflict, its origins and its ongoing impact are often appropriated by India and Pakistan. In the process, Kashmir has been reduced to a bilateral affair between the two nations, with indigenous voices being silenced. To anyone wanting to learn more about the conflict, I think it becomes essential to peel through the statist narratives and explore the human dimension of the dispute. At its core, one finds countless stories of loss, violence, trauma and a desperate longing for a peaceful future.

What does Kashmir mean to non-Kashmiris?

In terms of states, Kashmir still plays an integral role in India and Pakistan’s internal politics as well as in their unique political imaginations. One sees political actors in and out of power using the Kashmir cause to garner popular support even today. On a people-to-people level, Pakistanis also continue to profess a deep emotional connection to Kashmir, sympathising with Kashmiris and often also registering protest against the ongoing violence in the Valley. However, periodic polls conducted by Gallup Pakistan do reveal a shift in sentiments over the years; in particular there seems to be dwindling optimism amongst Pakistanis regarding conflict resolution.

It must also be noted that for many people in India and Pakistan, Kashmir is often only imagined as the Kashmir Valley and to be Kashmiri is seen as closely linked with the Kashmiri language, spoken predominantly by the people of the Valley. As a consequence other important stakeholders, like the Azad Kashmiris, are frequently ignored in conversations about the present and future of Jammu & Kashmir. Contrary to this line of thought, many Azad Kashmiris explained that Kashmiri identity is a political identity, which transcends linguistic barriers and is central to how they see themselves.

Why hasn’t the region (on both sides) received the attention it deserves?

Partially this is due to the protracted nature of the conflict. Kashmir receives local and international attention periodically, only to be overshadowed by other news overtime. However, partly this is also due to the fact that India and Pakistan’s narratives on Kashmir have often taken dominance, with local voices and perspectives being silenced or forgotten.

Within Jammu & Kashmir, Azad Kashmir in particular receives little attention. Given the increasingly tense socio-political climate across the LoC and the number of casualties there, narratives from Indian-administered Kashmir have understandably been documented more. Since Azad Kashmir is often viewed in juxtaposition to the ‘other side’ and since the region is – comparatively speaking – far more peaceful, its own politics and aspirations have not been explored enough.

After decades of turmoil do Kashmiris still feel strongly for their cause (azadi or freedom)? Do they have regrets? Do they yearn for the “normal”? Will there ever be a solution to this?

In Azad Kashmir, many Kashmiris still staunchly support the azadi cause – this ‘azadi’ is understood as independence from India. There is also some nationalist sentiment on this side, advocating for a united independent state of Jammu & Kashmir. However, I did come across people – particularly families living by the LoC and bearing the brunt of cross firing – who say they are sick and tired of the fight for azadi and just want peace. While they ideologically may still support the cause, in practical terms they realise that the fight seems unending and they are desperate for some sense of normalcy to return to their homes and lives. We are speaking of countless children who have grown up in bunkers, of countless lives lost to mortar shelling, of irreparable psychological damage – their call for peace echoes loudly in the border villages I traveled through.

Which is that one story that hit your heart the hardest?

The story of a mother whose young son was hit by a mortar while he was on his way to work. A car raced over his body right after, crushing him underneath. His family told me of how they collected his flesh and bones in their hands so they could hold his funeral: ‘maine apne haath se uska gosht andar kiya taki uska janaza go sake.’ This was during the 1990s when mortar shelling was at its height, with many women and children from this family spending days at length in dark, suffocating bunkers that I later visited. Each story they narrated from these years shook me, their resilience most extraordinary.

What if you had access to Kashmiris on the Indian side – how different would the book have been then?

A significant portion of the book explores the impact of ceasefire violations on people living by the LoC. Unfortunately both India and Pakistan tend to only report on losses on the sides administered by them. Casualties on the other side are frequently ignored. While I am aware that the experiences of villagers across the LoC mirror victims’ narratives of shelling in Azad Kashmir, I was unable to speak to people there. Adding their voices to the book – particularly of how they survive the constant state of uncertainty and vulnerability – would certainly provide a more holistic picture of what it means to live on one of the most volatile lines of division.  

Is this book a natural progression to Footprints of Partition? Your next?

Yes, in some ways. My interest in oral histories that developed during the process of researching and writing The Footprints of Partition has been further strengthened in Between the Great Divide. The oral history method has been instrumental in understanding the personal impact of the Kashmir conflict, allowing me to deconstruct consequences of state policies and enabling me to explore narratives ignored or sidelined in mainstream discourse. During this process I also realized that since my work on Partition was largely restricted to Punjab for my first book, my understanding of the divide and its repercussions was also limited in many ways. Exploring the human impact of Partition through Kashmir’s lens unearths new understandings of 1947 and its ongoing journey. In the near future, I plan to continue using the oral history method to study personal memories and the state’s role in the reconstruction of conflicts in the popular imagination of South Asia.



Enjoyed this story? Share it.


Lamat R Hasan
About the Author: Lamat is an Associate Editor at Asia News Network.

Eastern Briefings

All you need to know about Asia


Our Eastern Briefings Newsletter presents curated stories from 22 Asian newspapers from South, Southeast and Northeast Asia.

Sign up and stay updated with the latest news.



By providing us with your email address, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.

View Today's Newsletter Here

Curiosity

Muscular solid-fuel rocket to fly soon

The rocket will be used for space exploration. China Aerospace Science and Industry Corp will soon launch the nation’s biggest solid-propellant carrier rocket and is working on new models that will be even larger and stronger, a project insider said. Hu Shengyun, a senior rocket designer at the CASIC Fourth Academy in Wuhan, Hubei province, which develops and builds the Kuaizhou series, said the maiden mission of the Kuaizhou 11 will take place soon at the Jiuquan Satellite Launch Center in northwestern China. He spoke to China Daily on the sidelines of the ongoing second session of the 13th National People’s Congress in Beijing as he attends the national legislature’s annual meeting. The researcher said the Kuaizhou 11 is China’s largest and most powerful solid-propellant carrier rocket, with a length of 25 meters, a diameter of 2.2 meters, and a liftoff weight of 78 metr


By China Daily
March 14, 2019

Curiosity

Cloud Seeding: Why make it rain?

The South Korean government carried out its first artificial rain experiment of the year in late January. The trial was conducted by the Korea Meteorological Administration and the Ministry of Environment over the Yellow Sea. The results of this attempt were underwhelming, producing little more than a weak mist. Although the experiment has been reported as a “failure” the purpose of these operations isn’t necessarily to produce rain every time, but rather to acquire data, fine-tune the process and find out if artificial rain can even be reliably stimulated. The KMA carried out 12 experiments in 2018 and has 14 more trials planned for 2019. The data gathered by these trials will be used alongside information obtained from the 54 South Korean artificial rain experiments that h


By Quinn Libson
March 1, 2019

Curiosity

Hanoi gridlocked for Trump-Kim summit

The city is pulling out all the stops for the international summit. Hanoi traffic is manic enough on normal days, but it has got much worse this week as the city pulls out all stops for the second summit between United States President Donald Trump and North Korea leader Kim Jong Un. Downtown was gridlocked for much of Tuesday (Feb 26), as roads were blocked to make way for the arrivals of the two men, sending legions of scooters – the favoured mode of travelling for 7.5 million Hanoians – fleeing onto pavements to cut the jam. For this one week at least, life in Vietnam’s capital city will be far from normal. Cafes have been told to clear their tables and chairs from pavements; some have been told to shut. Tanks have rolled in, much to the amusement of both tourists and locals, who cannot resist posing next to the armoured vehicles. Yet, hotel receptionist Tam Mai, 30,


By The Straits Times
February 27, 2019

Curiosity

Japanese retailers embark on sales drive marking end of Heisei reign

The Japanese Emperor Akihito is due to abdicate later this year. Three months remain in the Heisei era. Unlike the previous era change brought about by the death of Emperor Showa, the upcoming transition is characterized by a festive mood. Retailers are engaging in a marketing war as they entice consumers with “Last Heisei” sales, while bridal companies are preparing for a wave of “last-ditch marriages” in which couples wed before the end of the era. The Loft, a leading variety store in Shibuya, Tokyo, put up an advertisement with the message, “We’re daring to ‘bring back’ giri-choko for the last Valentine’s Day of the Heisei era.” The campaign seeks to upend the gradual decline of giri-choko, chocolates that women give to their male colleagues or friends only out of a sense of obligation.


By The Japan News
February 3, 2019

Curiosity

Asia’s largest LGBTQ exhibition to open in Bangkok later this year

The exhibition will run from March through next year. “Spectrosynthesis II- Exposure of Tolerance: LGBTQ in Southeast Asia”, the largest-ever survey of regional contemporary art, will explore gender issues and feature more than 200 works by 50 artists. It will open at the Bangkok Art and Culture Centre (BACC) on November 23 and run until March 1 next year. The exhibition received huge critical acclaim when it was first staged in Taiwan 2017, after which its Hong Kong-based organiser, the Sunpride Foundation, chose Bangkok as its second stop. “Bangkok is my second home and Thailand is the most friendly LGBT country in Asia and the more liberal nation,” said Patrick Sun, founder of Sunpride Foundation. “Taiwan is the one of th


By The Nation (Thailand)
January 10, 2019

Curiosity

Ex-ambassador urges former colleague to defect to South Korea

A feature story from Korean Herald outlining the intricacies of a possible defection by Pyongyang’s ambassador in Italy. A former senior North Korean diplomat who defected to the South in 2016 on Saturday urged a former colleague who has gone into hiding before ending his term in Italy to come to Seoul, as opposed to the US where he is reportedly seeking asylum. Thae Yong-ho, who was the deputy ambassador in London and the most recent senior diplomat to defect, wrote an open letter to Jo Song-gil, 44, until recently North Korea’s acting ambassador to Italy, who fled the Rome embassy with his wife in early November without notice. Jo became


By The Korea Herald
January 7, 2019