See More on Facebook

Diplomacy

South Korea court ruling will affect relations with Japan

A ruling by South Korea’s supreme court allowing forced labourers during World War II to seek compensation with a Japanese firm could have lasting repercussions.


Written by

Updated: November 1, 2018

South Korea’s top court ruled on Tuesday that labourers forced into service during the second world war by the Japanese could seek compensation. The court ordered  Nippon Steel & Sumitomo Metal Corporation to pay  100 million won ($87,700) to the four plaintiffs in the case.

The court disregarded a 1965 treaty normalizing relations between the two countries which Tokyo said nullifies the plaintiffs’ claims.

Protest 

The decision was met with criticism from the Japanese government with Foreign Minister Taro Kono asking the South Korean government to remain committed to previous agreements, according to the Yomiuri Shimbun.

In telephone talks with his South Korean counterpart Kang Kyung Wha, Kono pressed the South Korean government to ensure that Japanese nationals and corporations suffer no ill effects from the court’s ruling.

During the talks, Kono reiterated Japan’s position that the issue of compensating former requisitioned workers was “completely and ultimately resolved” under the 1965 agreement on the settlement of problems concerning property and claims and on economic cooperation. He also said Tokyo “viewed the matter as extremely grave because the legal foundation of the two countries has been fundamentally damaged.” Kang responded by saying the Korean government was discussing how to deal with the matter.

Seoul is expected to decide its position after consulting relevant ministries and experts on the issue.

Japan eyes legal action

“We’ll do whatever we can. We’ll show our intention to protect Japanese companies,” a high-ranking Japanese government official said Tuesday after the ruling, according to the Yomiuri Shimbun.

In response to Tuesday’s ruling, the Japanese Foreign Ministry set up an office in its Asian and Oceanian Affairs Bureau to deal with bilateral property and claim issues, and began full-scale preparations for a legal response.

Meanwhile, South Korea’s Foreign Affairs Ministry spokesman Noh Kyu Duk said Tuesday at a press conference: “We, as a government, are considering various possibilities. We must put our heads together to keep the latest judgment from negatively affecting Japan-South Korea relations.”

No great ideas

According to South Korean government sources, Seoul has approached Tokyo in the past through back channels to form a foundation funded by both governments, South Korean firms and defendant Japanese companies to handle compensation payments. This suggestion was rejected by the Japanese government.

If bilateral talks break down, the Japanese government will suggest, based on the agreement, the formation of an arbitration commission including an arbitrator from a third nation.

There is no precedent for forming such a commission. The two countries might not be able to agree on the selection of the third-party arbitrator. If this happened, the Japanese side might file a complaint with the International Court of Justice (ICJ), but even then a trial is likely not to be convened, as South Korea has not accepted the obligation to attend ICJ trials.

One reason why the South Korean government tries to avoid settlement through an arbitration commission or the ICJ is that “losing will spur public finger-pointing, causing tremendous harm to the Moon administration,” a Japan-South Korea diplomatic source said.

Even if an ICJ trial would not be held, the Japanese government is still considering filing a complaint, to show international society that South Korea breached international law.

The Moon administration has taken an ambiguous approach, trying to balance domestic public opinion and the Japan-South Korea relationship. It acted in a similar way regarding a bilateral agreement signed at the end of 2015 over the issue of former comfort women, where the administration did not abolish nor renegotiate the deal but still has not accepted it.

Fourteen similar cases regarding former requisitioned workers are currently pending in South Korea, and the latest court ruling may trigger a flood of orders for Japanese firms to pay compensation. Tokyo plans to urge Seoul to take measures to prevent the latest case from becoming a judicial precedent.

 



Enjoyed this story? Share it.


Cod Satrusayang
About the Author: Cod Satrusayang is the Managing Editor at Asia News Network.

Eastern Briefings

All you need to know about Asia


Our Eastern Briefings Newsletter presents curated stories from 22 Asian newspapers from South, Southeast and Northeast Asia.

Sign up and stay updated with the latest news.



By providing us with your email address, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.

View Today's Newsletter Here

Diplomacy

Saudi Crown Prince arrives in India

Ready to share intelligence, cooperate with India to eliminate terrorism: Saudi Crown Prince. India and Saudi Arabia on Wednesday exchanged memorandums of understanding (MoUs) after talks by Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman. MoUs on tourism, cooperation in the field of housing, International Solar Alliance among others were exchanged between the two countries. On his first state visit to the country, Prime Minister Narendra Modi welcomed the Saudi Crown Prince saying that Saudi Arabia was India’s “close friend”. India and Saudi Arabia have a longstanding relationship, PM Modi said adding that in the 21st century, Saudi Arabia was among India’s most important strategic partners. The Prime Minister, in a joint press conference with Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman, also welcomed Saudi investment in Indian infrastructure. I


By The Statesman
February 21, 2019

Diplomacy

Imran Khan responds to Indian accusations after attack

Pakistan will address actionable evidence if shared by Delhi, PM Khan tells India after Pulwama attack. In a video message, Prime Minister Imran Khan on Tuesday said Islamabad will take action if Delhi shares any actionable evidence concerning last week’s suicide bombing in occupied Kashmir’s Pulwama area which had targeted Indian paramilitary soldiers. While offering cooperation and another chance at a dialogue over the Kashmir issue, the premier also warned India against any act of aggression, saying Pakistan will not hesitate in retaliating to a provocation. However, he made it clear that he hopes better sense will prevail. The premier explained he


By Dawn
February 20, 2019

Diplomacy

Saudi Arabia accuses Iran of being state-sponsor of terrorism

Saudi minister calls out Iran for ‘accusing others’ while being ‘world’s chief sponsor of terrorism’. Saudi Minister of State for Foreign Affairs Adel bin Ahmed Al-Jubeir on Monday accused Iran of sponsoring terrorism for decades, saying it was “strange [for] the foreign minister of the world’s chief sponsor of terrorism to accuse others of engaging in terrorist activities”. The minister, who is part of Saudi Crown Prince Mohammad bin Salman’s visiting delegation, was addressing a joint press conference with Foreign Minister Shah Mahmood Qureshi in Islamabad. When asked about 


By ANN Members
February 19, 2019

Diplomacy

Good outcomes expected for Trump-Kim summit

Vietnam News takes a look at the reaction on the street as anticipation builds in Vietnam over summit. early 3,000 journalists are expected to descend on Hanoi next week for the biggest political event of the year. US President Donald Trump and North Korea’s Supreme Leader Kim Jong-un will come face-to-face in Vietnam’s capital city on February 27 and 28. It’s only the second time the political heavyweights have ever met, but analysts predict this meeting has more significance than last year’s summit in Singapore. “I think we can expect some good outcomes from this summit,” Lê Hồng Hiệp, a Vietnamese International Relations expert based in Singapore, told Vietnam News. “In the first summit, parties only committed to some vaguely worded commitments. “I think President Trump would expect to have some significant outcomes from the summit to contribute to


By Viet Nam News
February 19, 2019

Diplomacy

Saudi Arabia signs 20 billion USD in agreements with Pakistan

‘Pakistan will be a very important country in coming future,’ says Saudi crown prince. Saudi Crown Prince Mohammad bin Salman on Sunday expressed optimism about the economic future of Pakistan, saying his country had been waiting for a leadership like that of Prime Minister Imran Khan to partner with Islamabad in various areas. Addressing a reception dinner at Prime Minister House hours after arriving in Pakistan, the crown prince — known as MBS for short — said Pakistan is a “dear country” to all Saudis and that the two countries “have walked together in tough and good times”. He said Pakistan today had a great future in store “with a great leadership”, and noted that the country’s GDP grew by 5 per cent in 2018. “We believe that P


By Dawn
February 19, 2019

Diplomacy

Experts rule out possibility of key agenda shift in US-NK summit

Key changes are unlikely as Trump prepares to meet Kim in Vietnam. Analysts here have downplayed the possibility that the US might only seek to avoid a nuclear attack from North Korea directed at the country during their upcoming summit, following US President Donald Trump’s remarks that he is not in a rush to denuclearize North Korea. While taking credit for averting a war with Pyongyang, Trump said he expects the second summit with North Korean leader Kim Jong-un, slated for Feb. 27-28 in Vietnam, to as successful as the first, where the two leaders had pledged to work toward the complete denuclearization of the Korean Peninsula. “I’m in n


By The Korea Herald
February 18, 2019