See More on Facebook

Diplomacy

S. Korea top court: Mitsubishi owes damages

Fallout continues over South Korean ruling that Mitsubishi owes war time reparations.


Written by

Updated: November 30, 2018

 South Korea’s Supreme Court dismissed appeals by Mitsubishi Heavy Industries Ltd. on Thursday, upholding lower court rulings in two lawsuits that ordered the company to pay damages to South Korean former workers who were mobilized from the Korean Peninsula during World War II.

In one lawsuit, filed by five former requisitioned workers, the top court ordered Mitsubishi Heavy to pay compensation of 80 million won (about ¥8 million) to each of the plaintiffs.

In the other lawsuit, filed separately by five other plaintiffs, including members of the Korean Women’s Volunteer Labor Corps, the top court ordered Mitsubishi Heavy to pay compensation of 100 million won to 150 million won (about ¥10 million to ¥15 million) to each plaintiff.

The court decision finalized the cases, in which the Japanese company has lost.

In legal battles over former requisitioned labor, the South Korean top court handed down its first ruling on Oct. 30 by ordering Nippon Steel & Sumitomo Metal Corp. to pay damages. The latest two rulings followed the precedent set by that top court decision. At least 12 similar suits, including one for which a high court ruling was due to be handed down later on Thursday afternoon, have been pending in lower courts. Japanese companies are highly likely to face rulings that will order them to pay compensation in succession.

As a South Korean support group has begun preparations to file new lawsuits, the relationship between Japan and South Korea appears set for inevitable worsening.

Regarding the issue of former requisitioned workers’ right to seek compensation, the Japanese government has taken the stance that the issue has been “settled completely and finally” under the 1965 Agreement on the Settlement of Problems concerning Property and Claims and on Economic Cooperation between Japan and the Republic of Korea. Under the administration of President Roh Moo-hyun in 2005, the South Korean government also acknowledged that the individual right to seek compensation by former requisitioned workers and relevant others was not recognized. Tokyo has strongly urged Seoul to deal with the issue appropriately.

On Thursday, however, the top court ruled that the 1965 agreement does not cover the right of the plaintiffs and relevant others. The court recognized their right to compensation for “illegal acts against humanity committed by a Japanese company in direct connection with Japan’s illegal colonial rule and war of aggression against the Korean Peninsula.”

Regarding the defendant’s argument that the statute of limitations for making claims has expired, the top court said it upheld the lower court’s ruling that rejecting the performance of obligations to the plaintiffs is unjustified and amounts to the abuse of power, which is against the principle of good faith and trust.

The lawsuit involving the former requisitioned workers was filed with the Busan District Court in May 2000. The district and high court rulings went against the plaintiffs. After the Supreme Court dismissed the high court ruling in May 2012 and remanded the case, the Busan High Court ordered Mitsubishi Heavy to pay compensation in July 2013. The five former requisitioned workers have died, and 23 other people, including their surviving family members, have taken over the case as the plaintiffs.

The other lawsuit was filed by former members of the Korean Women’s Volunteer Labor Corps, and surviving family members, with the Gwangju District Court in October 2012. The plaintiffs won the case at the district and high courts.

Mitsubishi Heavy appealed the rulings in both cases to the Supreme Court.

The plaintiffs of the two lawsuits and others also participated in damages suits filed in Japan against the company, but Japan’s Supreme Court dismissed the plaintiffs’ claims in 2007 and 2008.

MHI: Rulings regrettable

Following Thursday’s rulings, Mitsubishi Heavy Industries (MHI) issued a statement, saying, “These rulings are deeply regrettable, as they violate the [1965] agreement and are contrary to the view of the Japanese government and the final and binding judgments of the Supreme Court of Japan.”

“Going forward, MHI will take appropriate measures while maintaining communication with the Japanese government about this issue,” it added.

Kono decries rulings

Foreign Minister Taro Kono strongly protested the rulings by the South Korean Supreme Court upholding damages payments to wartime workers.

“These decisions are extremely regrettable and totally unacceptable … Above all, the decisions completely overthrow the legal foundation of the friendly and cooperative relationship that Japan and the Republic of Korea have developed since the normalization of diplomatic relations in 1965,” he said in a statement.

Kono said the issue of seeking compensation has been “settled completely and finally” under the 1965 agreement. He strongly urged the South Korean government to take appropriate measures, including immediate action to remedy such a violation of international law.

If appropriate action is not taken immediately, Kono said in the statement, “Japan will continue to examine all possible options, including international adjudication and countermeasures and take resolute actions.”

On Thursday, Vice Foreign Minister Takeo Akiba summoned South Korean Ambassador to Japan Lee Su Hoon to the Foreign Ministry and lodged a protest over the matter.

The South Korean Foreign Ministry said after the rulings that it respects the decisions by the judicial branch. The ministry called the Japanese government’s “continuing excessive reaction” to the rulings “very regrettable.”



Enjoyed this story? Share it.


The Japan News
About the Author: The Japan News is published by The Yomiuri Shimbun, which boasts the largest circulation in the world.

Eastern Briefings

All you need to know about Asia


Our Eastern Briefings Newsletter presents curated stories from 22 Asian newspapers from South, Southeast and Northeast Asia.

Sign up and stay updated with the latest news.



By providing us with your email address, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.

View Today's Newsletter Here

Diplomacy

Attempts to isolate

Would a re-elected Modi rethink his Pakistan policies. Imran Khan and the military leadership have been expressing a desire for improved relations with India. But India is unlikely to respond anytime soon. And the reasons go beyond its upcoming elections. I recall here a private briefing some of us South Asia hands in Washington got from a close adviser of Narendra Modi soon after he took office as prime minister. Unaware of my identity, he spoke of Pakistan with contempt. “We are going to treat Pakistan as if it were on the other side of a high wall,” he said. Four years on, the adviser is there as is India’s Pakistan policy. How has the policy endured for so long? The search for the answer opens up a vast landscape of policy, politics and ideology in India. Beginning in 1991, India has been on a steady march to foster external relations conducive


By Dawn
February 15, 2019

Diplomacy

Investor Jim Rogers to visit North Korea next month

The famed investor will visit Pyongyang at Kim Jong-un’s invitation. Jim Rogers, a renowned investor and chairman of Rogers Holdings, plans to visit North Korea next month at the invitation of Chairman Kim Jong-un, according to sources Tuesday. The Singapore-based investor, who once said he would “put all of my money” in North Korea if he could, received the US government’s approval for the trip with his wife. The billionaire has touted the impoverished country with a gross domestic product per capita of $1,800 as an attractive investment destination for five years, even before the thawing of inter-Korean relations last year.


By The Korea Herald
February 13, 2019

Diplomacy

China refutes Turkey’s Uighur claims

Turkey called for re-education camps to be closed and accused China of killing a popular musician. China on Monday strongly rejected Turkey’s “absurd lie” about the death of a Uygur folk musician, saying the Turkey’s claim extremely wrong and irresponsible. “China has made solemn representations to Turkey and is firmly opposed to its groundless accusations,” Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Hua Chunying said at a regular news conference in Beijing. In a statement released on Saturday, the Turkish Foreign Ministry criticized the human rights situation in the Xinjiang Uygur autonomous region and claimed that Abdurehim Heyit, who was sentenced to eight years in prison, had died. But Heyit appeared in a video released by China Radio International on Sunday. He said, “I’m in the process of being investigated for allegedly violating national laws” and &


By China Daily
February 13, 2019

Diplomacy

China dismisses EU spying charge

Chinese embassy dismisses groundless report about alleged Chinese espionage in Brussels. The Chinese Embassy in Belgium on Sunday dismissed recent local media report about alleged Chinese espionage in Brussels as an outright fabrication. Responding to the news report by some local media alleging that “there are about 250 Chinese spies active in Brussels,” a spokesperson of the Chinese Embassy in Belgium said the report “is an outright fabrication without any evidence.” “China and Belgium now enjoy a steadily growing relationship and fruitful cooperation across all fields. China is committed to developing sound relations and cooperation with Belgium and all other countries on the basis of mutual respect, equality and mutual benefits,” the spokesperson said in a statement. “Some specific irresponsible remarks aimed to maliciously discredit China, mislead an


By China Daily
February 12, 2019

Diplomacy

China, US to talk trade in Beijing next week

Trade talks designed to break deadlock and end tariffs which have slowed down both economies. US President Donald Trump has announced that US Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer and Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin will head to Beijing for trade talks on Feb 14-15, the White House said Friday morning. The principal-level meetings, following discussions that took place on Jan 30-31 in Washington, will be preceded by deputy-level negotiations that will begin on Feb 11, led by Deputy USTR Jeffrey Gerrish, according to a statement from the White House Press Secretary Office. Carlos Gutierrez, former US Secretary of Commerce, said that trade disputes are bad for both sides. “So I would hope that we have reached the limit in terms of escalation, and that we can continue the dialogue to reach an agreement,” he said in an interview on Wednesday. Last week, top Chinese and US trade


By China Daily
February 11, 2019

Diplomacy

South Korea, US ink provisional defense cost-sharing pact

Getting allies to pay ‘their fair share’ has been a major part of President Trump’s rhetoric. South Korea and the United States signed a provisional agreement Sunday on the sharing of costs to maintain US troops here, with South Korea raising its share by 8.2 percent. Seoul’s negotiator, Chang Won-sam, and his US counterpart, Timothy Betts, met in Seoul to ink the contract. Under the new deal, South Korea will pay about 1.03 trillion won ($890 million) to cover the costs of stationing the 28,500 members of US Armed Forces Korea here throughout 2019. The figure reflects the rate of increase of South Korea’s annual defense budget, according to the Foreign Ministry in Seoul. Last year, South Korea paid about 960 billion won to its ally for the same purpose.


By The Korea Herald
February 11, 2019