See More on Facebook

Business

Apple says Korea should not interfere in issues with telecom operators

The tech giant says that regulators should leave its interactions with local telecom companies alone.


Written by

Updated: January 15, 2019

South Korea’s top antitrust watchdog should not interfere in business dealings between Apple and local mobile carriers, which should operate by market rules, Apple’s legal representative in Korea said.

“The FTC should not waste its resources on business dealings legally made by the market mechanism and based on long negotiations between Apple and Korean telecom companies (SKT, KT and LG Uplus),” Oh Keum-seok, a partner at Seoul’s BKL law firm that represents Apple, told The Korea Herald.

“If Apple faces sanctions from the FTC, this will set a bad precedent for foreign companies doing business in Korea,” he said.

The remark comes before the Fair Trade Commission’s second council is slated to take place. During Wednesday’s council, Apple will defend the case brought by the FTC, which suspects that Apple Korea has unfairly passed the costs for iPhone sales, including advertising costs, launch events and repair costs to local mobile carriers.

After raiding the Apple Korea office twice, in 2016 and 2017, the FTC sent an examination report to the firm in April of last year to seek an explanation over alleged unfair practices.

“All the current business practices (between Apple and telecom firms) are made based on the contracts signed more than a decade ago when Apple first came to Korea. At the time, Apple was not in a position to make contracts to its advantage because the local handset market was dominated by Korean firms, Samsung and LG,” Oh said.

Apple’s iPhone first came to Korea in 2008 via local mobile carrier KT. Subsequently, SKT and LG Uplus signed deals with the US handset maker in 2011 and 2014 respectively. Apple claims the articles of the contracts have not changed since, although the amount for advertising costs borne by mobile carriers has increased in proportion to the rise of iPhone’s market share in Korea. The detailed amount is not open to the public due to confidentiality, the lawyer said.

For the second council, FTC Chairman Kim Sang-jo has said he would review the issue from an economic perspective. Both FTC and Apple will accompany economic professors.

“We are confident our argument will be more persuasive when the case is viewed from the economic perspective. This is because Apple fully abides by market rules,” he said.

The third and last council is estimated to take place at the end of next month, upon which a determination will be made on a penalty. If Apple is convicted, the firm is subject to a fine of up to 2 percent of related sales.

On top of a fine, the FTC may or may not decide to impose corrective measures that would require major changes in the transaction terms, which Apple fears would have a greater impact by setting a precedent in the global market.

The FTC declined to comment, as the councils are ongoing.

In other nations, Apple faced a penalty of 700 million won ($620,000) in Taiwan in 2013 for controlling iPhone costs and was imposed with a fine of 64 billion won in France over unfair practices against carriers last year.



Enjoyed this story? Share it.


The Korea Herald
About the Author: The Korea Herald is the nation’s largest English-language daily and the country’s sole member of the Asia News Network.

Eastern Briefings

All you need to know about Asia


Our Eastern Briefings Newsletter presents curated stories from 22 Asian newspapers from South, Southeast and Northeast Asia.

Sign up and stay updated with the latest news.



By providing us with your email address, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.

View Today's Newsletter Here

Business

Huawei asks US court to overturn ban

The company is suing the FCC, the latest in a series of legal tussles. The legal battle between Huawei Technologies Co and United States government intensified on Thursday. The Chinese tech heavyweight announced a legal challenge to the US Federal Communications Commission, seeking to overturn the latter’s order that bans telecom carriers from buying the company’s equipment via federal subsidies. The move is the latest push by the world’s largest telecom equipment maker to pursue fair competition and treatment amid a slate of restrictions from Washington. Analysts said the FCC ban would have very limited impact on Huawei’s financial performance, but labeling the company as a national security threat would cause far-reaching reputational harm. In a petition filed in the US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit on Thursday, Huawei asked the court to declare the FCC order un


By China Daily
December 6, 2019

Business

Is Vietnam an attractive place for Samsung chip plant?

The tech giant already has manufacturing plants in the country. Is Vietnam a good place for chipmakers to consider building a high-tech plant? In light of a request by the Vietnamese head of state to Samsung Electronics, the world’s largest chipmaker, many in South Korea are asking whether it is a viable business move. In a private meeting held in Seoul on Thursday, Vietnamese Prime Minister Nguyen Xuan Phuc asked Samsung Electronics Vice Chairman Lee Jae-yong to consider building a chip manufacturing facility there. The Korean tech giant already has production plants for mobile phones and other IT devices in the country. Following the re


By The Korea Herald
December 2, 2019

Business

Nepal’s luxury hotels are growing but the rooms are empty

There are 15 five-star hotels in the country, and a dozen more are being planned even as existing hotels continue to report a significant drop in profit. High-end hotels might be proliferating across the country but there aren’t enough guests to fill them up, according to the financial reports of Nepal’s three key five-star institutions. The first quarter financial reports from Taragaon Regency Hotels, Soaltee Hotel and Oriental Hotels, all of which are listed on the Nepal Stock Exchange, showed that profits have taken a nosedive after posting record profits last fiscal year. The first quarter of the fiscal year runs from mid-July to the end of September. The three hotel groups say that unhealthy competition, like price undercutting, a demand-and-supply gap, and a growing number of backpackers are behind the sharp fall in earnings. According to its report, Oriental Hotels, which operates Radi


By The Kathmandu Post
November 21, 2019

Business

Huawei to match Google’s mobile services by Q1 2020

The company to support more Android apps on its phones. Huawei may soon be able to offer Android developers a full range of the essential mobile services required for their apps as the ones provided by Google. This would allow more Android apps to work on new Huawei phones affected by a ban that forbids the use of Google mobile services on these handsets. Mr Zhang Ping’an, president of Huawei Consumer Cloud Service told The Straits Times in an interview at Huawei’s Asia-Pacific Developer Day last Wednesday (Nov 13) that Huawei Mobile Services can “replace 90 per cent of Google Mobile Services by December”. These mobile services from Google and Huawei are used by developers to enable key functions in their mobile apps to, for


By The Straits Times
November 21, 2019

Business

Excessive discounts worked against Nissan Motor profits

The company has been on the back foot since its former CEO was accused of mismanagement. Nissan Motor Co. has reported a massive 85 percent decline in operating profits — an area that indicates the strength or weakness of a company’s main business — in its midterm consolidated financial report for the half fiscal year ending in September. The pursuit of increased sales has harmed profitability, delaying the development of new Nissan models. That in turn has resulted in fewer sales — a vicious cycle the automaker is struggling to escape from. Nissan Motor’s deteriorating business performance may affect its three-way partnership with Renault SA, the French automaker that is its largest shareholder, and Mitsubishi Motors Corp. Failed strategy by Ghosn Nissan Corporate Vice President Stephen Ma, who will become chief financial officer on Dec. 1


By The Japan News
November 14, 2019

Business

US property loses allure for Chinese buyers

Economic factors contribute to falling demand.  Over the past 10 months, Bei Qin, a realtor in Silicon Valley, California, has not had any clients from China, a market that used to be her major source of business. “We had the best business in 2016 and 2017. Every day, we had inquiries from Chinese buyers and every week our WeChat account had more than 10 new subscribers,” said Qin, president of ACEQ Investment Group in Cupertino. “Now those days are gone.” After a decade of increasing investment by wealthy Chinese in residential property purchases in the United States-the biggest proportion of international buyers for seven consecutive y


By China Daily
November 12, 2019