See More on Facebook

Current affairs, Economics

Cash handouts a precursor universal basic income in India?

Is universal basic income around the corner in India.

Written by

Updated: +00

Is the beginning of direct benefit transfer of funds to India’s most marginalised citizens which the country’s Budget for the financial year starting 1 April unveiled in terms of a massive handout for small farmers the holy grail in the fight against debilitating and widespread poverty? Is it, as the Wall Street Journal asked in a recent article, a possible prelude to implementing a universal basic income in India?

The emerging political consensus in India seems to indicate that the answer to both questions is in the affirmative.

The government of Prime Minister Narendra Modi, in its last Budget before it goes up for re-election in general elections scheduled for April-May this year, promised pay-outs to poor farmers – well over 50 per cent of Indians are still dependent on agriculture for a living — through the direct benefit transfer (DBT) mode.

The DBT model has been advocated for long by economists and policymakers across the political divide as the best way of helping the poor as it puts money into individual bank accounts and virtually eliminates the possibility of leakages whether due to systemic inefficiencies or corruption.

Though the individual pay-out announced by the government for small and marginal farmers is modest – each farmer gets a little over 250 dollars per annum in his/her account paid out in three tranches of 80-odd dollars every four months – the total outlay for the scheme given the sheer number of citizens it seeks to help, around 120 million farming families, would cost a whopping 10.5 billion dollars a year.

The Indian Prime Minister was quick to point out in an election rally just a day after the Budget was presented in Parliament that the scheme is valid in perpetuity with no end-date, which in effect already makes it a quasi-basic universal income scheme for a large section of the distressed farmer families of rural India who own less than five acres of agricultural land.

Senior Minister (without portfolio) Arun Jaitley, who has been in-charge of the Finance Ministry from the very beginning of the Modi Administration and is currently recuperating from an illness in the US, followed that up in an interview from hospital on 3 February in which he stressed that the quantum of the pay-out could be increased with the passage of time and as the government’s resources grow. He also pointed out that various state or provincial governments could top-up the central government’s pay-out with their own localised income support schemes.

These moves are clearly aimed at taking on the poll promise made by Rahul Gandhi, president of the Congress Party and Modi’s main challenger in the forthcoming polls, that if voted to power his party would introduce a Minimum Income Guarantee for every poor person in the country which he announced a few days before the Budget clearly taking the ruling party by surprise. Details of his proposal have not been made public though party spokespersons have been insisting that the blueprint is ready and will be announced at an appropriate time. Gandhi himself was dismissive of the “pittance” he accused the Modi Administration of allocating for small farmers as income support and said his party would do much better to ensure universalisation of the income guarantee for India’s poor both rural or urban.

There is unanimity in India that a bidding war for support at the hustings has begun. In the process, India missed its fiscal deficit target which was set at 3.3% of GDP for the year ending in March but will end up at 3.4% of GDP and there is uncertainty about next year’s. There is also some concern among economists about how any government – regardless of political persuasion — will find the money to fund an ambitious Universal Basic Income scheme.

In theory, an annual pay-out of 106 dollars to 75% of India’s poor population could be implemented if it replaces all existing programs and subsidies which would partially offset the cost of implementing a Basic Universal Income scheme that is estimated will be about 5% of GDP. While a little over 100 dollars a year may not seem much to most, for many Indians living on less than a dollar a day it could mean life above the poverty line. While details of how such a program would be implemented haven’t been released by either of the two national political parties, they appear to be versions of universal basic income plans which are being debated around the world.

An Indian government paper in 2017 had first sparked serious discussion about the issue by suggesting the country could eventually benefit from such a program. “Universal Basic Income may simply be the fastest way of reducing poverty. UBI is also, paradoxically, more feasible in a country like India where it can be pegged at relatively low levels of income but still yield immense welfare gains,” the report said.

It seems increasingly a question of when, not if.

Enjoyed this story? Share it.

Asia News Network
About the Author: Asia News Network is a regional media alliance comprising 24 media entities.

Eastern Briefings

All you need to know about Asia

Our Eastern Briefings Newsletter presents curated stories from 22 Asian newspapers from South, Southeast and Northeast Asia.

Sign up and stay updated with the latest news.

By providing us with your email address, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.

View Today's Newsletter Here

Current affairs, Economics

Japanese government to establish organization to keep eye on IT firms

The body will scrutinize financial dealings by tech giants. The government is finalizing plans for a new organization dedicated to comprehensively monitoring the business dealings of large IT companies and formulating policies to ensure transparency in their practices. The new regulator will be established as early as this autumn inside the Cabinet Secretariat. The Fair Trade Commission likely will be able to conduct unannounced checks on these companies based on information collated by the new organization. The new body also will consider legislation pertaining to fair business transactions involving large IT companies. On Wednesday, Prime Minister Shinzo Abe instructed a meeting of the Council on Investments for the Future to consider how such a specialist organization should operate. During the meeting held at the Prime Minister’s Office,

By The Japan News
February 15, 2019

Current affairs, Economics

STATEMENT: Asia News Network condemns arrest of Rappler’s Maria Ressa

Ressa was arrested by the Philippines government for libel. The Asia News Network notes with concern and alarm the arrest of Maria Ressa, executive editor and CEO of leading Philippine news site Rappler, for pursuing the truth in a case with significant ramifications for society. Her arrest, on grounds that raise concern, violates the freedom that media organisations need to have, to play their part as a key pillar of functioning democracies. This is particularly important in Asia where systems of democratic representation, accountability and legal recourse are at various stages of nascent development, with much room for improvement and need for safeguarding. We are seriously disturbed by the manner of her arrest and we urge the Philippine government to refrain from any form of intimidation against the media. We note Rappler’s statement that the warrant for her arrest dated February 12, 201

By Asia News Network
February 14, 2019

Current affairs, Economics

Rappler’s Maria Ressa arrested for cyber libel

Ressa is once again behind bars after Duterte’s government’s arrested the Rappler CEO. Rappler’s Chief Executive Officer Maria Ressa was arrested inside her news agency’s headquarters in Pasig City on Wednesday over a cyber libel case. Agents of the National Bureau of Investigation (NBI) conducted the arrest at around 5 p.m., even as the warrant was already issued by the Manila Regional Trial Court Branch 46 on Tuesday, February 12. READ: Court orders arrest of Rappler CEO Maria Ressa As she was being ushered out of her office, Ressa said she was shocked by her sudden arrest. “It’s a shock, but we are going,” she told reporters. She also said that the NBI agents treated her professionally during the serving of the warr

By Philippine Daily Inquirer
February 14, 2019

Current affairs, Economics

China, US to talk trade in Beijing next week

Trade talks designed to break deadlock and end tariffs which have slowed down both economies. US President Donald Trump has announced that US Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer and Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin will head to Beijing for trade talks on Feb 14-15, the White House said Friday morning. The principal-level meetings, following discussions that took place on Jan 30-31 in Washington, will be preceded by deputy-level negotiations that will begin on Feb 11, led by Deputy USTR Jeffrey Gerrish, according to a statement from the White House Press Secretary Office. Carlos Gutierrez, former US Secretary of Commerce, said that trade disputes are bad for both sides. “So I would hope that we have reached the limit in terms of escalation, and that we can continue the dialogue to reach an agreement,” he said in an interview on Wednesday. Last week, top Chinese and US trade

By China Daily
February 11, 2019

Current affairs, Economics

Japanese Ground Self-Defense Force to be sent to Sinai Peninsula

The troops will be utilized in an observing capacity. The government plans to send Ground Self-Defense Force members to the Sinai Peninsula in eastern Egypt to monitor a ceasefire between the Israeli and Egyptian militaries as part of the Multinational Force and Observers, multiple government sources said. This would be the first time for the government to apply new provisions on internationally coordinated operations for peace and security (see below) that were part of the security-related laws that went into force in March 2016. The deployment could happen as early as spring. The government decided to respond to a request from the MFO because it believes helping maintain the ceasefire between Israel and Egypt is important to ensuring a stable supply of energy from the Middle East, which Japan relies on for energy. A four-minister meeting of the National S

By The Japan News
February 11, 2019

Current affairs, Economics

Japan, Britain to jointly invest in science and technology research

Both governments will survey areas of potential overlapping interests. The Japanese and British governments plan to set up a working-level panel to jointly invest in science and technology research, The Yomiuri Shimbun has learned. The two governments will exchange memorandums of agreement on the issue as early as this month and begin selecting research subjects. According to sources, six organizations will participate in the panel: the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science, the Japan Science and Technology Agency and the Japan Agency for Medical Research and Development — all of which provide research assistance — and the Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology Ministry, and Britain’s Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy and the U.K. Research and Innovation body. It will be the first time Japan has joined with a foreign co

By The Japan News
February 8, 2019