See More on Facebook

Current affairs, Economics

Cash handouts a precursor universal basic income in India?

Is universal basic income around the corner in India.

Written by

Updated: +00

Is the beginning of direct benefit transfer of funds to India’s most marginalised citizens which the country’s Budget for the financial year starting 1 April unveiled in terms of a massive handout for small farmers the holy grail in the fight against debilitating and widespread poverty? Is it, as the Wall Street Journal asked in a recent article, a possible prelude to implementing a universal basic income in India?

The emerging political consensus in India seems to indicate that the answer to both questions is in the affirmative.

The government of Prime Minister Narendra Modi, in its last Budget before it goes up for re-election in general elections scheduled for April-May this year, promised pay-outs to poor farmers – well over 50 per cent of Indians are still dependent on agriculture for a living — through the direct benefit transfer (DBT) mode.

The DBT model has been advocated for long by economists and policymakers across the political divide as the best way of helping the poor as it puts money into individual bank accounts and virtually eliminates the possibility of leakages whether due to systemic inefficiencies or corruption.

Though the individual pay-out announced by the government for small and marginal farmers is modest – each farmer gets a little over 250 dollars per annum in his/her account paid out in three tranches of 80-odd dollars every four months – the total outlay for the scheme given the sheer number of citizens it seeks to help, around 120 million farming families, would cost a whopping 10.5 billion dollars a year.

The Indian Prime Minister was quick to point out in an election rally just a day after the Budget was presented in Parliament that the scheme is valid in perpetuity with no end-date, which in effect already makes it a quasi-basic universal income scheme for a large section of the distressed farmer families of rural India who own less than five acres of agricultural land.

Senior Minister (without portfolio) Arun Jaitley, who has been in-charge of the Finance Ministry from the very beginning of the Modi Administration and is currently recuperating from an illness in the US, followed that up in an interview from hospital on 3 February in which he stressed that the quantum of the pay-out could be increased with the passage of time and as the government’s resources grow. He also pointed out that various state or provincial governments could top-up the central government’s pay-out with their own localised income support schemes.

These moves are clearly aimed at taking on the poll promise made by Rahul Gandhi, president of the Congress Party and Modi’s main challenger in the forthcoming polls, that if voted to power his party would introduce a Minimum Income Guarantee for every poor person in the country which he announced a few days before the Budget clearly taking the ruling party by surprise. Details of his proposal have not been made public though party spokespersons have been insisting that the blueprint is ready and will be announced at an appropriate time. Gandhi himself was dismissive of the “pittance” he accused the Modi Administration of allocating for small farmers as income support and said his party would do much better to ensure universalisation of the income guarantee for India’s poor both rural or urban.

There is unanimity in India that a bidding war for support at the hustings has begun. In the process, India missed its fiscal deficit target which was set at 3.3% of GDP for the year ending in March but will end up at 3.4% of GDP and there is uncertainty about next year’s. There is also some concern among economists about how any government – regardless of political persuasion — will find the money to fund an ambitious Universal Basic Income scheme.

In theory, an annual pay-out of 106 dollars to 75% of India’s poor population could be implemented if it replaces all existing programs and subsidies which would partially offset the cost of implementing a Basic Universal Income scheme that is estimated will be about 5% of GDP. While a little over 100 dollars a year may not seem much to most, for many Indians living on less than a dollar a day it could mean life above the poverty line. While details of how such a program would be implemented haven’t been released by either of the two national political parties, they appear to be versions of universal basic income plans which are being debated around the world.

An Indian government paper in 2017 had first sparked serious discussion about the issue by suggesting the country could eventually benefit from such a program. “Universal Basic Income may simply be the fastest way of reducing poverty. UBI is also, paradoxically, more feasible in a country like India where it can be pegged at relatively low levels of income but still yield immense welfare gains,” the report said.

It seems increasingly a question of when, not if.

Enjoyed this story? Share it.

Asia News Network
About the Author: Asia News Network is a regional media alliance comprising 24 media entities.

Eastern Briefings

All you need to know about Asia

Our Eastern Briefings Newsletter presents curated stories from 22 Asian newspapers from South, Southeast and Northeast Asia.

Sign up and stay updated with the latest news.

By providing us with your email address, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.

View Today's Newsletter Here

Current affairs, Economics

Vietnam to be among world’s most dynamic markets by 2030

The country has reached amazing levels of progress in the last two decades. With an emerging market economy and continued strong growth, Vietnam is set to become one of the most dynamic markets in the world by 2030, according to Euromonitor International, a global market research company. An Hodgson, Euromonitor International’s income and expenditure research manager, said the company’s research database showed that urbanisation, with the associated concentration of income, wealth and population, would propel Việt Nam’s commercial success by 2030. Published last month, the research database has found that Vietnam will be the third biggest urban market by consumer numbers and fifth biggest by total spending in Southeast Asia. By 2030, the country’s urban consumer market will expand to 46 million consumers and $169 billion worth of spending. GDP growth is expected to rea

By Viet Nam News
June 13, 2019

Current affairs, Economics

China blames ‘lawlessness’ for Hong Kong

Lawlessness undermining rule of law in Hong Kong, says China Daily editorial. The government of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region has explained many times the proposed amendments to Hong Kong’s fugitive law are meant to better protect Hong Kong society by plugging the loopholes in the existing laws in order to enhance the rule of law. Rather than pushing through a bill against the wishes of Hong Kong society as some have tried to portray, the government has made changes to the proposed bill more than once in response to concerns expressed in the community. As a result, most of the members of Legislative Council of the special administrative region, who are accountable to their voters, now support the amendments. Nor is it a hasty or unnecessary move. Indeed the need for an extradition agreement with the mainland was acknowledged by government officials and legal experts ahead of H

By China Daily
June 13, 2019

Current affairs, Economics

Hong Kong protests turn violent

At least 72 people taken to hospital during clashes with police. At least 72 people were injured and taken to hospital during clashes between police and protesters on Wednesday (June 12) over a contentious extradition Bill, said Hong Kong authorities. By night time, police officers were still in a stand-off with protesters on Queensway, not far from Admiralty Station, even though most of the protestors had dispersed following the use of tear gas and rubber bullets. Earlier, police fired rubber bullets at protesters after they declared a “riot” as – for the second time in days – clashes broke out between police and protesters demonstrating against the controversial extradition Bill.

By The Straits Times
June 13, 2019

Current affairs, Economics

Li pledges to improve business climate

Li Keqiang says China taking steps to open up economy to foreign businesses Premier Li Keqiang reaffirmed China’s commitment to improving its business environment by deepening reforms to streamline administration and carrying out large-scale tax cuts and fee reductions. Li said in a meeting on Tuesday with World Bank President David Malpass that the country will bring its business environment more in line with market principles, international standards and the rule of law as part of efforts to promote high-quality development. He noted China’s cooperation with the World Bank, which is in keeping with its steps in reform and opening-up and benefited the country’s growth. The global landscape is complex and fluid, and the Chinese economy is facing various risks and challenges, he said. Further cooperation between China and the World Bank will help promote poverty reduction, narrow

By China Daily
June 12, 2019

Current affairs, Economics

Restrictions on Chinese firms could drive up 5G cost

China is increasing pressure on consumers in a bid to end restriction on its major tech firms. Europe would have to pay an extra 55 billion euros ($62 billion) for 5G networks and suffer an 18-month technology delay if it bans telecom equipment purchases from top Chinese manufacturers, according to an industrial report. The report by the GSM Association, which represents 750 mobile operators worldwide, said Ericsson, Nokia and Samsung, the non-Chinese contenders in the 5G market, do not have the capacity to handle all of the shift from 3G and 4G networks to 5G in Europe while honoring contracts already signed in North America and Asia. Huawei and ZTE account for about 40 percent of the EU market, and Huawei is “currently a pioneer in 5G technology”, according to the GSM analysis, first reported by Reuters and Agence France-Presse on Friday. “A ban on Chinese v

By China Daily
June 11, 2019

Current affairs, Economics

Malaysia finds mass influx of undocumented workers from Bangladesh

5,272 undocumented Bangladeshis held in Malaysia in 5 months. Malaysian immigration department has detained 5,272 Bangladeshi workers among other nationals between January 1 to June 4 this year amid the country’s stringent actions against undocumented foreign workers. During this time, the immigration department carried out 7,940 operations nationwide, involving checks on over 100,000 foreigners and took actions against 23,295 undocumented foreign workers, reports Malaysian newspaper Free Malaysia Today, quoting a statement by Malaysian Home Minister Muhyiddin Yassin on Sunday. Of those detained, 8,011 are Indonesians, 5,272 are Bangladeshis, and the rest include workers from Myanmar, Philippines and Thailand, the report read. “In the five months between January 1 and June 1, 2019, some 26,116 illegal immigrants were sent back to their respective countries,” the statement said. The n

By The Star
June 11, 2019