See More on Facebook

Diplomacy, Opinion, Politics

Opinion: India expected too much of Pakistan’s best friend

Indian diplomats and leaders should know that world leaders expect that India should be able to take care of its own military problems with its troublesome neighbor.


Written by

Updated: February 25, 2019

It is not known how the visit of the Saudi Crown Prince would have gone off at levels that were dealing with the visit and interacting with the visitor. Going through the newspapers and viewing television, it might not have been as successful as desired. One of the main reasons might have been the overwhelming emphasis that was laid on declaring Pakistan a terror state.

To begin with the manner in which the Saudi Prince was received must have been perceived by him as deferential seeing India’s size and its standing in the world. It was duly taken note of. Possibly it was gratifying but it would also lead to an appreciation that the Crown Prince had the upper hand in his dealings with the Indian Prime Minister. This is also the impression that many Indians might have got, not to speak of foreign governments and their representatives in India.

Making condemnation of Pakistan the topmost item on the agenda was a mistake. Surely, the MEA and the PM would have known that Saudi Arabia and Pakistan have been joined at the hip since Pakistan was created. No two states are closer than these two. During his visit to Pakistan, the Crown Prince said that for all Saudis Pakistanis were the closest of friends. The Saudi-Pakistan relationship is closer than that Islamabad has with America or China. Our diplomats, many of whom have been close to the Saudis, would know that Saudi Arabia has been subsidising oil shipments to Pakistan for a long time.

Pakistan’s nuclear programme right from inception was largely financed by Libya and Saudi Arabia. The headquarters of the Pakistan Cricket Board in Lahore are at Gaddafi Stadium. It is the home of Pakistan cricket team. It was named after Libyan leader Muammar Gaddafi. Pakistan was financed by these two Arab countries.

Being the principal equity-holders of the Pakistani venture both expected access to nuclear know-how and weapons when the need arose. The Libyan issue was peacefully resolved when its leader offered to give up his nuclear weapons in December 2003 and to open his facilities for inspection. He paid the price for his decision a few years later. Libya continues to be in turmoil, no one knowing when and how it will end.

Saudi Royals who visited Pakistan in the past were shown around top-secret nuclear facilities. They know that the guardians of the nuclear weapons hold them in trust for the Guardians of Islam’s holy sites. It makes each side indispensable to the other. Additionally, Pakistan military has traditionally been deployed in Saudi Arabia for providing close protection to the Saudi royals. It has varied from a division to a brigade. General Raheel Shareef the former Army chief of Pakistan Army has been co-opted by Saudi Arabia to head the Gulf military force that has been raised. He would be privy to everything to do with Saudi defence, their weapons holding, projected intake and state of readiness. He would be a trusted adviser in this regard.

Iran felt that it was obliged to go in for its nuclear capability on account of these threats to its existence in addition to the threat posed by Israel and its ally, the US. That is why it can never trust Pakistan even when relations appear to be cordial.

Reverting to India making the question of Pakistani terrorism the main plank of its discussions, and for the Crown Prince to go along with his hosts to declare his close ally a sponsor of terrorism was a demand that no Saudi royal would have acceded to no matter how terrible the outrage. It was beyond the Prince’s ken to do so.

At the end Indian diplomats and leaders should know that world leaders expect that India having the fastest growing economy in the world and looking to be an important player on the global stage should be able to take care of its own military problems with its troublesome neighbor. No doubt it would like to take all possible measures to isolate Pakistan in world forums. However, shrill denunciation at every forum has become painful to hear for most listeners.

The world is fed up with constant bickering between the two nations at the UN since the last 70 years. Today many countries around the world are exposed to terrorism, mainly by radicalised Muslims affiliated to Al Qaeda and lately ISIS. In Afghanistan and in Jammu and Kashmir, especially the Kashmir Valley, terrorists are backed, trained and supplied sophisticated weapons and explosive devices by the Pakistan military, the ISI and the tanzeems in Pakistan that have proliferated. Every attack needs to be condemned.

Foreign governments do take note of every such attack, especially between nuclear neighbours. Pakistan’s denials have no credibility anywhere. Friendly powers have been offering help to India by way of shared intelligence and by several other means. That is why Pakistan’s financial aid has been cut off.

India’s purpose in this regard is being served. It must now make its calls for declaring its western neighbor a terrorist state in a more sophisticated and quiet manner.

(The writer, a retired Major General of the Indian Army, is an observer of international affairs)



Enjoyed this story? Share it.


The Statesman
About the Author: The Statesman is one of India’s oldest English newspapers and a founding member of Asia News Network.

Eastern Briefings

All you need to know about Asia


Our Eastern Briefings Newsletter presents curated stories from 22 Asian newspapers from South, Southeast and Northeast Asia.

Sign up and stay updated with the latest news.



By providing us with your email address, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.

View Today's Newsletter Here

Diplomacy, Opinion, Politics

Moon highlights value of Korea-US alliance

Moon made the statements at a high level meeting between South Korean and US officials. President Moon Jae-in on Tuesday highlighted the importance of the South Korea-US alliance, saying the alliance remains firm and serves as the foundation of his drive for peace. The meeting was attended by South Korean Minister of National Defense Jeong Kyeong-doo and Gen. Robert Abrams, chief of the US Forces Korea. Other participants included Gen. Park Han-ki, chairman of South Korea’s Joint Chiefs of Staff, the commanding generals of the country’s Army, Navy and Air Force, and USFK Deputy Commander Lt. Gen. Kenneth S. Wilsbach. During the meeting


By The Korea Herald
May 22, 2019

Diplomacy, Opinion, Politics

Modi party confident of new India election victory

Exit Polls show the BJP in the lead after the end of elections. Voting in India’s mammoth national election ended Sunday with the seventh and final phase of a grueling poll that lasted more than five weeks, as exit polls predicted a victory for Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Hindu nationalist party and its allies, The Associated Press reported. While opposition parties refused to concede and the country faces a nerve-jangling three-day wait until the official count begins, most media polls said Modi’s Bharatiya Janata Party, or BJP, and its allies would secure enough seats to form a new government after the world’s biggest election, according to Agence France-Presse. Exit polls by four leading television news channels-Republic, TimesNow, New Delhi Television and India today-projected a victory for the BJP and its allies with 287 to 339 seats out of 543. That would be far ahea


By China Daily
May 22, 2019

Diplomacy, Opinion, Politics

Five reasons why many Indians voted for Modi’s BJP

A analysis piece in Dawn by Supriya Sharma looks at why Indian voters chose Modi, again. “Five minutes. Do nothing. Let things happen.” This is what Bheru Lal believes Narendra Modi said after a train was burnt down in Godhra in 2002, allowing Muslims to be killed under his watch as chief minister. The 26-year-old Bhil Adivasi, who drives a taxi in Udaipur, Rajasthan, heard this story in 2014. It pleased him enough to make him vote for the Bharatiya Janata Party that year. In April, he said he was voting for the party again. We will soon know how many Indians made the same choice – not all for the same reason as Bheru Lal, though his anti-Muslim views seem to have chillingly wide currency in the country. Majoritarianism surfaced in innumerable conversations I had with voters in four states – Maharashtra, Bihar, Rajasthan and Uttar Pradesh – while reporting The Modi Voter


By Dawn
May 22, 2019

Diplomacy, Opinion, Politics

South Korea likely to reject arbitration committee on wartime workers

The Japanese and Korean governments are at loggerheads over the issue of forced labour during the war. The government on Monday demanded that the South Korean government agree to the establishment of an arbitration committee to resolve a lawsuit filed by former Korean wartime requisitioned workers in which Japanese companies were ordered to pay compensation, government officials said. The demand was made based on the 1965 bilateral agreement on the settlement of problems concerning property and on economic cooperation. The government deemed it necessary to shift to an arbitration process involving a third party, which should be more enforceable, as South Korea has rejected bilateral negotiations on the issue. However, Seoul is unlikely to agree to the demand, and the prospects are slim that the strategy will lead to resolving the issue. “We’ve determine


By The Korea Herald
May 22, 2019

Diplomacy, Opinion, Politics

Jokowi winner of elections

The Indonesian General Election Commission have named Joko Widodo winner of the presidential elections. The General Elections Commission (KPU) has officially declared President Joko “Jokowi” Widodo the winner of the April 17 presidential election after completing the national vote tally in the early hours of Tuesday morning. The final tally showed that the Jokowi-Ma’ruf Amin pair secured 85 million votes (55.5 percent), while the Prabowo Subianto-Sandiaga Uno pair garnered 68 million votes (44.5 percent). KPU head Arief Budiman said the losing candidate pair could challenge the election result at the Constitutional Court within three days of the official announcement of the vote tally. If there is no legal challenge, the KPU will officially name Jokowi and Ma’ruf duly elected as president and vice president for the 2019-2024 period on Friday, Arief said. The Prabowo camp ha


By The Jakarta Post
May 21, 2019

Diplomacy, Opinion, Politics

The death of Thailand’s oldest party

If the Democrats join the pro-military government, it could spell the end for the party. They say that the pursuit of democracy is a Sisyphean ordeal, a never-ending task that must be kept at and pursued constantly. The Democrat Party, the country’s oldest, would have you believe that it has, through its long history, been the champion of Thai democracy – that it has fought valiantly against the impulses of totalitarianism whenever they occurred. Yesterday, the pro-junta, pro-military Palang Pracharat Party said it had convinced the Bhumjaithai Party and the Democrats to join a coalition which would allow it to form a government. If this proves to be true, then the Democrat Party will no longer exist. It would no longer serve the illusory purpose its proponents claim was its birthright; after all, how can one defend democracy when one sides with


By Cod Satrusayang
May 21, 2019