See More on Facebook

Analysis, Culture and society

Fighting fake news in Asia

Across Asia, governments are putting in place measures to prevent the spread of fake news via social media.


Written by

Updated: August 28, 2019

US President Donald J Trump may have done a singular disservice to the global effort to fight misinformation on multiple platforms by categorising professional media critical of him as purveyors of ‘fake news’.

The impact of conflating professional and social media is a particular concern in Asia, as governments put in place legislation and measures to contain fictitious information flows masquerading as factual reportage online.

It is, therefore, helpful to keep in mind that mainstream professional media – while it can and does get it wrong on occasion – is rarely guilty of malintent.

And when it is, there are extant laws including civil/criminal legal remedies to prosecute these exceptions for defamation, slander and libel.

Fake news, on the other hand, is arguably very much an exclusively social media linked phenomenon.

Several Asian countries rely heavily on social media for information, making them particularly vulnerable to the spread of fake news (see Nikkei Asian Review chart below).

WHAT IS FAKE NEWS?

As the BBC puts it: “The problem of deliberately falsified news articles, masquerading as properly-researched journalism, goes back centuries.”

Although disinformation has always existed, a range of new tools such as social media and messaging apps have made it easier to spread falsehoods. “Fake news is made-up stuff, masterfully manipulated to look like credible journalistic reports that are easily spread online to large audiences,” according to a widely quoted definition by PolitiFact.

Sober voices in government and media broadly accept that the absence of a professional filter before the dissemination of incendiary opinion, purported facts and bias dressed up as reportage has the potential to cost lives, spark societal conflagrations and slander reputations of individuals/organisations.

In Asia, given the right to free speech is subject to reasonable restrictions in most if not all countries, this has resulted in calls for regulation of social media to prevent the spread of fake news which many governments have been mulling or have acted on over the past few weeks and months.

ASIA OVERVIEW

In South Korea, last week, the Moon Jae-in administration pledged to intensify its efforts to eradicate what it perceives as misleading news content that could undermine economic and security prospects. The Korea Herald reported on 21 August: “The government is stepping up efforts to prevent fake news from undermining its major policy initiatives.”

“While dealing with the serious economic situation, we should be cautious about the possibility that fake news, falsified information and exaggerated prospects could increase market instability,” Moon is quoted to have said by the newspaper during a Cabinet meeting on 13 August.

The immediate trigger for his remarks appeared to be what he saw as biased criticism of his security and economic initiatives. Content containing harsh criticism of his North Korea policy and the trade dispute with Japan has been overflowing on YouTube and other online platforms.

In India, earlier this week, the country’s top constitutional court restrained a High Court from passing final orders on a public interest litigation asking for interlinking of citizens’ social media profiles with their unique national identity number database for authentication of identity.

The petition, which reportedly has its supporters in the Narendra Modi Administration, argues that this interlinking was necessary to tackle fake news and other cybercrimes.

Privacy concerns have naturally come to the fore. But the rampant spread of fake news and rumours via social platforms which have been identified as the triggers for multiple incidents of mob violence by investigating agencies, for example, has provided resonance to the petitioners’ plea.

Just under two months ago, Singapore’s controversial Protection from Online Falsehoods and Manipulation Act (POFMA) was voted into law. It empowers any Singaporean government minister to issue a range of corrective directions against online ‘falsehoods’ deemed to be against the public interest.

Elvin Ong and Isabel Chew of the University of British Colombia writing in the East Asia Forum make the point that “the law over-invests power in the executive by allowing it to determine what a falsehood is and what is contrary to the public interest.”

But, as The Straits Times reported, ministers’ decisions are open to judicial review. And the ‘better safe than sorry’ approach of the Singapore law seems to have found societal acceptance.

POFMA itself came on the back of Malaysia’s 2018 Anti-Fake News Act enacted under the previously long-ruling Barisan Nasional (BN) regime which was repealed last week  (16 August).

Bucking the trend in Asia, Minister Mohamed Hanipa Maidin told lawmakers: “There are sufficient laws to deal with fake news; new legislation isn’t needed. We already have existing laws, such as the Communications and Multimedia Act 1998 and others.” The BN regime had been criticised by the ruling Pakatan Harapan coalition for using the Act to stifle its voice when it was in opposition.

Indonesia launched its cyber security agency last year as the world’s biggest Muslim majority country moved to tackle online religious extremism and a flood of fake news on social media. It has been highly active as millions of Indonesians are going online for the first time – more than 150 million out of 255 million Indonesians are now said to be Internet users – just as concern about fake news reaches fever pitch.

In Sri Lanka, the government introduced five-year jail terms in June this year for those caught spreading fake news and hate speech on social media following a surge in online vitriol and disinformation in the aftermath of the Easter suicide terror attacks. Offenders will also be fined one million rupees. The penal code is being amended to introduce the new penalties.

Cambodia introduced its own fake news law last year under which anyone posting misinformation on social media or websites can be punished with up to two years in jail and fines of US$1,000. All websites have in recent weeks been told they must register with Cambodia’s Ministry of Information.

The Phnom Penh Post reported Prime Minister Hun Sen had warned that his government was employing technology with which it could home in on any Facebook user in “only six minutes”.

From 1 January this year a new Cybersecurity Law came into effect in Vietnam which requires the likes of Facebook and Google to open offices and store data in the country, remove ‘toxic’ fake news content from their platforms when asked to by government and, in specific cases for law enforcement, hand over user data to the authorities.

The government has fended off criticism and is implementing the law vigorously as “dissemination of fake news and cyberattacks directly cause serious economic losses and threaten security/social so must be curbed”.

In the Philippines, an anti-fake news bill was proposed in 2017 in the Senate. This was eventually incorporated into an updated version of the penal code wherein it is now ‘unlawful for any person to maliciously offer, publish, distribute, circulate or spread false news and information’.

The case of independent journalist Maria Ressa, founder of online news platform Rappler, is well known – earlier this year, both Ressa and Rappler were slapped with charges of cyber libel for a report that was published before the libel law came into effect.

President Rodrigo Duterte has made no secret of his dislike for Rappler, accusing the platform of being owned by US investors and carrying ‘fake news’ as recently as a couple of weeks ago.

As for Thailand, it adopted the Computer-Related Crime Act in 2016, a law that equips the government with the ability to clamp down on anyone propagating information online it deems ‘false’.

A more mature media, though, has been emphasising the need for educating the public on issues around fake news. The Nation urged the government and professional media to emulate the Finnish effort to curb fake news:

“Statistics show Finland’s patient and comprehensive campaign to halt the spread of fake news is starting to see positive results. A key element of the strategy is education – teaching young students to be alert to falsities they encounter online, to be wary of what’s presented as fact and to be resourceful about verifying information.”

WHAT NEXT?

A research paper titled Trends in the Diffusion of Misinformation on Social Media by Hunt Allcott of New York University, Matthew Gentzkow of Stanford University and Chuan Yu of Stanford University, is simpatico to the argument proffered by tech companies running major social media platforms that their interventions to prevent fake news are making a difference and that’s the way forward to curb the menace while simultaneously protecting free speech:

In recent years, there has been widespread concern that misinformation on social media is damaging societies and democratic institutions. In response, social media platforms have announced actions to limit the spread of false content.

We measured trends in the diffusion of content from 570 fake news websites and 10,240 fake news stories on Facebook and Twitter between January 2015 and July 2018… Our results suggest that efforts to limit the diffusion of misinformation… may have had a meaningful impact.

But national governments across Asia have obviously not been impressed and are leading sovereign crackdowns on fake news, some justifiable others not so much, which are likely to intensify.

Pro free speech arguments such as those of Malaysian lawyer and human rights activist R Sivarasa – who once noted with a mixture of sarcasm and pathos that his country’s Constitution guarantees freedom of speech “but not freedom after speech” – appear to have been trumped by the intervention of technology and its misuse.



Enjoyed this story? Share it.


About the Author:

Eastern Briefings

All you need to know about Asia


Our Eastern Briefings Newsletter presents curated stories from 22 Asian newspapers from South, Southeast and Northeast Asia.

Sign up and stay updated with the latest news.



By providing us with your email address, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.

View Today's Newsletter Here

Analysis, Culture and society

8 Coast Guard personnel found guilty in death of Taiwanese fisherman

The case stems from an incident in 2013. The Manila Regional Trial Court Branch 15 has found eight members of the Philippine Coast Guard (PCG) guilty in the death of Taiwanese fisherman Hong Shi Cheng off  Batanes in 2013. Found guilty were Commanding Officer Arnold Dela Cruz, Seaman 1st Class (SN1) Edrando Aguila, SN1 Mhelvin Bendo II, SN1 Andy Gibb Golfo, SN1 Sonny Masangcay, SN1 Henry Solomon, SN1 Richard Corpuz and Seaman 2nd Class Nicky Renold Aurelio. The incident strained the relationship between Taiwan and the Philippines.As a result of the incident, the Taiwanese government has stopped the issuance of visas to Filipinos workers seeking jobs in Taiwan. The Philippines sent a representative and delivered the government’s official letter of apology to soothe the strained relations. The PCG in 2013 said its personnel acted in self defense when it opened fire at Taiwanese fishing ve


By Philippine Daily Inquirer
September 18, 2019

Analysis, Culture and society

S.E. Asian manufacturing sees opportunity in U.S.-China row

By Shingo Sugime and Yoichiro Tanaka / Yomiuri Shimbun Correspondents. Southeast Asian countries are intensifying their efforts to attract companies planning to move production bases outside China, as the United States and China have become entrenched in tit-for-tat sanctions and retaliatory tariffs. To attract the needed outside investment, they are offering tax incentives and other benefits. ‘Thailand Plus’ “We see the U.S.-China trade frictions as an opportunity to expand our efforts to attract foreign companies,” Thai Deputy Prime Minister Somkid Jatusripitak told reporters after a Cabinet meeting on Sept. 10. On that day, the Thai government adopted what it calls the “Thailand Plus” package of preferential measures for companies that relocate factories and other facilities from China. A corporate tax deduction of up to 50 p


By The Japan News
September 18, 2019

Analysis, Culture and society

Pakistan and India face common threats, climate change is the biggest one

Collective action may just be what is needed to secure the lives and livelihoods of future generations. Climate change is no longer limited to books or scientific papers; it is a reality knocking on our doors. Longer, sweltering summers bringing in record-breaking heat to South Asia are just one example. The harshest of conditions have yet to come, and the entire region is woefully unprepared to meet the challenges. While they may seem isolated, increasing instances of extreme weather are harbingers of a major climate shift for South Asia. Unlike transnational challenges like security and trade, climate change cannot be deterred by conventional methods or unilateral initiatives. Instead, synchronised common action is the viable way forward for sustainable progress to mitigate the impacts of climate change. Let’s look at some of the common environmental challenges facing Pakistan


By Dawn
September 17, 2019

Analysis, Culture and society

South Korea and Japan have more in common than they think

Republished with permission for Asia News Network members by The Brookings Institution. With South Korea’s decision to scrap the 2016 military intelligence sharing agreement with Japan, the two sides have dramatically aggravated their fraught relationship. Bilateral ties had never been great, but in the past several weeks, a trade spat has snowballed into a confrontation that apparently has yet to reach rock bottom. Last month, Tokyo decided to remove South Korea from its list of favored trading partners, which includes the United States, Germany, France, and two dozen other countries, placing export curbs on industrial and high-tech p


By Asia News Network
September 16, 2019

Analysis, Culture and society

Can Global Exchanges work?

Andrew Sheng for Asia News Network. HKEx’s (0388.HK) audacious $32 billion bid for London Stock Exchange Group (LSE.L) raised quite a few eyebrows on 9/11.   Three immediate questions were raised by the bid.   First, does the bid make sense for shareholders on a commercial basis?  Second, what are the strategic considerations for Hong Kong and global financial markets?  Third, what are the regulatory and geopolitical hurdles? My own policy is never to make any predictions on the prices or viability of any commercial deal but to let facts speak for themselves.   At present prices, HKEx is the third largest listed exchange in the world with a market cap of $40 billion, larger than the LSE ($31 billion) but smaller than the CME Group ($77 billion) and the Intercontinental Exchange Inc (ICE, $53 billion).   The fact that the LSE share price rose slightly after the bid announcement but remained lower th


By Asia News Network
September 16, 2019

Analysis, Culture and society

The foreigner who stoked political chaos in Malaysia

For Asia News Network Editor’s Circle by Chong Lip Teck of Sin Chew Daily. Controversial Indian Muslim preacher Zakir Naik is on the wanted list in India due to his extreme religious remarks and alleged involvement in money laundering. Many Muslim countries have denied him entry. But in Malaysia, he is well received by the Pakatan Harapan (PH) government. Within the coalition, however, there is a split because of him. The ground sentiment is also divided into two, on  racial and religious lines. One side has defended him while the other side asked for his repatriation. As a Muslim preacher, Zakir Naik is popular in the Muslim community. He has his charm. While promoting Islam, he would  downgrade other religions, especially the Hindus and Christians. But, as a guest in Malaysia, he has crossed the red line. If he is merely promoting Islam, no one is against him. But he insults other religions in his sp


By ANN Members
September 16, 2019