See More on Facebook

Diplomacy, Politics

Kashmir represents a new opportunity for Pakistani politics

Will Islamabad seize the opportunity.

Written by

Updated: August 29, 2019

CAN Pakistan convert the recent crisis in India-held Kashmir (IHK) into an opportunity to begin an entirely new phase on how the world perceives the dispute and how it views Pakistan? The answer must go beyond an obvious ‘yes’ to formulating and implementing a bold, vigorous communications strategy to supplement the diplomatic strategy being actively pursued.

The prime minister and foreign minister are leading an energetic official campaign. Their stress on violations of UN resolutions as well as their caution that India is likely to stage fake terrorist incidents to divert attention and justify retaliatory action is apt and timely. Yet, while such efforts are forceful and receive some coverage in the international press, the primary consumers of the government’s message are the already-converted people of Pakistan — whereas the more relevant, and contextually more important, audiences are the billions outside Pakistan, particularly the thousands among them who shape their respective countries’ perceptions and policies.

While our own independent news media is consumed by millions, the global reach of our English language electronic media is extremely limited. Nor do we use Spanish, French, Chinese, Russian and other languages in our external media proportionate to the scale of the challenge. In recent months, the launch of a local English-language news channel is a promising new effort.

In the past weeks, some major international media outlets and parts of social media have been highly critical of India’s repression. But the months-long Hong Kong protests are given far more prominence than the plight of seven million Kashmiris over the past 72 years — and particularly since 1989 — facing the bayonets of over 700,000 Indian troops.

A new communications strategy should have three goals: (i) to revitalise and continuously update the world’s awareness on the cruel oppression in IHK; (ii) to confront and overcome the real or imagined ‘Kashmir fatigue’ factor in overseas countries (images of persons blinded by pellet guns to pictures of the thousands disappeared offer a powerful, persuasive resource); and (iii) to gradually change Pakistan’s predominantly negative image in most parts of the world.

This image is a tragic reality created, in turn, by three elements: (i) our own ill-advised policies during the 1980s/1990s that made extremism and violence synonymous with the country’s name; (ii) our failure to project the fact that the overwhelming majority of Pakistanis are moderate, friendly and peaceable — confirmed by virtually every first-time overseas visitor; and (iii) India’s success in maligning Pakistan by using diplomacy, academia, news media, cinema, and individuals of Indian origin penetrating Western policy and opinion-making processes.

As important as the goals are the idiom, tone and language that should be used to implement a new strategy. The focus should be on the right of self-determination rather than the presumptuous slogan of “Kashmir will become Pakistan”. The element of fascistic Hindutva should remain the prime message rather than Muslim religious affinity. Presentation of hard facts from, say, the 2018 UN Human Rights Council report should be temperate and modulated, not emotive and strident.

A comprehensive, multi-dimensional, sustained multi-media campaign is required. A wide range of modes should be used: purchase of space and time in influential print and electronic media in each major country to project the message, canvas for frequent references in editorial and programming content, and social media used innovatively. Teams of former diplomats, analysts and parliamentarians with proficiency in English and other languages should visit major cities across the world to express the message in a lucid, temperate, rational way. Centres should be opened across these hubs to project the rich culture of Pakistan and the Sufi humanism of the Kashmiri ethos. Prominent international media outlets should be invited to visit Azad Jammu & Kashmir and the Pakistani side of the Line of Control — access unavailable on the Indian side.

The proposed initiative should be a public-private collaboration. The public part should be facilitative, not bureaucratic; the private dimension agile yet disciplined. For a government facing severe financial restraints, at least three potential funding sources can be tapped: Pakistan-based philanthropists and corporate entities; overseas Pakistani professionals and business owners; and similarly, sections of the Kashmiri diaspora.

Historically, Pakistan has never conducted a systematic, prolonged campaign to project its positive facets and its righteous support for Kashmiri rights. Past efforts have been only sporadic, limited, didactic and grossly under-funded. Every dollar invested will bring five-fold gains. Let 2019 signal the start of a new global narrative by Pakistan.

The writer is a former senator and federal minister.


Enjoyed this story? Share it.

About the Author: Dawn is Pakistan's oldest and most widely read English-language newspaper.

Eastern Briefings

All you need to know about Asia

Our Eastern Briefings Newsletter presents curated stories from 22 Asian newspapers from South, Southeast and Northeast Asia.

Sign up and stay updated with the latest news.

By providing us with your email address, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.

View Today's Newsletter Here

Diplomacy, Politics

Pakistan strongly condemns India’s remarks about ‘having control’ of AJK one day

The remarks were made by India’s foreign minister. India’s foreign minister said on Tuesday that Azad Jammu and Kashmir belongs to India and that he expected New Delhi to gain physical control over it one day, raising the rhetoric over the territorial dispute. In response, Pakistan strongly condemned and rejected “the inflammatory and irresponsible remarks made by the Indian External Affairs Minister regarding Pakistan and AJK”, according to a statement by the Foreign Office. The statement also called upon the international community to take note of the “aggressive posturing”. India claims the heavily populated Kashmir Valley while Pakistan has a wedge of territory in the west of the disputed region — Azad Jammu and Kashmir. “Our position on [Azad Kashmir] is, has always been and will always be very clear. [Azad Kashmir] is part of India and we expec

By Dawn
September 18, 2019

Diplomacy, Politics

Rohingyas in Voter List: EC staffers, fraud ring behind it

Electoral fraud sees Rohingya on voting list. A nexus of brokers and some dishonest staffers of the Election Commission’s Chattogram office provides forged national identity cards to Rohingyas, an EC investigation team has found. Three members of the syndicate were arrested on Monday. An EC laptop, used in the forgery, was recovered from their possession, EC Deputy Director (NID) Iqbal Hossain, head of the three-member team, told The Daily Star yesterday. The arrestees are Jainal Abedin, 35, office assistant of Double Mooring Election Office under the Chattogram EC office, Bijoy Das, 23, a driver, and his sister Sima Das alias Sumaiya Jahan, 26, said Mohammad Mohsin, officer-in-charge of Kotwali Police Station. Yesterday, Double Mooring Thana Election Officer Pallabi Chakma filed a case against five people, including the three, with the police station under the Digital Security Act, the OC said

By Daily Star
September 18, 2019

Diplomacy, Politics

Japan officially removed from South Korea’s whitelist

Seoul has threatened the move for weeks. South Korea excluded Japan from its export controls whitelist Wednesday in retaliation for Tokyo’s earlier decision to remove Seoul from its list of favored trade partners, as bilateral relations have slumped to the lowest levels since normalizing diplomatic ties in 1965. “The Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy has published the revision of the nation’s trade controls on strategic items in an official gazette and it took effect from Wednesday,” said the ministry spokesperson through a statement. Since the Aug. 12 announcement by Industry Minister Sung Yun-mo that Korea would drop Japan as a preferred trading partner, the ministry has completed the necessary administrative steps, such as soliciting opinions from the public and submitting the revised rules to the Office of Legislation for review. “We have received opinions from the public throu

By The Korea Herald
September 18, 2019

Diplomacy, Politics

Beijing lauds Solomon Islands’ move to break ties with Taiwan authorities

The United States has condemned the move. China highly commends the decision of the Solomon Islands’ government to recognize the one-China principle and sever the so-called “diplomatic ties” with the Taiwan authorities, Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Hua Chunying said late on Monday. Hua’s comment came as the Pacific island nation decided earlier on Monday at a cabinet meeting that it would break the so-called “diplomatic ties” with the Taiwan authorities and establish diplomatic relationship with Beijing. Hua said in an online statement that Beijing supports the Solomon Islands’ government in “making such an important decision as a sovereign and independent country”. Beijing has made it clear that there is but one China in the world, that the government of the People’s Republic of China is the sole legal government that represents the who

By China Daily
September 18, 2019

Diplomacy, Politics

S.E. Asian manufacturing sees opportunity in U.S.-China row

By Shingo Sugime and Yoichiro Tanaka / Yomiuri Shimbun Correspondents. Southeast Asian countries are intensifying their efforts to attract companies planning to move production bases outside China, as the United States and China have become entrenched in tit-for-tat sanctions and retaliatory tariffs. To attract the needed outside investment, they are offering tax incentives and other benefits. ‘Thailand Plus’ “We see the U.S.-China trade frictions as an opportunity to expand our efforts to attract foreign companies,” Thai Deputy Prime Minister Somkid Jatusripitak told reporters after a Cabinet meeting on Sept. 10. On that day, the Thai government adopted what it calls the “Thailand Plus” package of preferential measures for companies that relocate factories and other facilities from China. A corporate tax deduction of up to 50 p

By The Japan News
September 18, 2019

Diplomacy, Politics

Pyongyang confirms ready to resume talks, but gives conditions

Foreign minister confuses lawmakers on whether North Korean leader’s letter to Trump was different to one already made public. The long-stalled US-North Korea working level talks on denuclearization could take place soon, a senior North Korea official signaled in a statement carried by the Korean Central News Agency on Monday that also set out conditions for the resumption of dialogue. The director general of the North Korean Foreign Ministry’s department of American affairs said working-level talks will likely take place in a few weeks. He said the two countries may forge closer relations or hostility depend on what Washington brings to the table. But he also set out a number of conditions.

By The Korea Herald
September 17, 2019