See More on Facebook

Hong Kong: The Ironies of Democracy and Freedom

Democracy and freedom begin with self-discipline which, within law and order, protects your own rights as well as the rights of others, writes Andrew Sheng.


Written by

Updated: October 11, 2019

There are two great ironies coming out of the current protests in Hong Kong.

First, whilst the rest of the world’s youth are coming out in protest against government inaction on climate change, some of the Hong Kong youth have come out violently for the cause of democracy and freedom.

The Swedish teenager Greta Thunberg, in her passionate “How Dare You” speech, shamed the elderly leaders at the United Nations for failing to act decisively to deal with the global climate change damage to what the next generation will inherit.  She was concerned about global common concerns. Right on!

Second, even as the Hong Kong youth wave the Union Jack and Stars and Stripes, these Western democracies are experiencing political crises bordering on chaos, with US impeachment and Brexit economic risks.

If electoral democracy means that the majority votes prevail, Donald Trump was elected president even though he won 2.87 million votes less than Hillary Clinton.

Boris Johnson is already a dysfunctional Prime Minister in a minority government in Parliament, leading the United Kingdom to a chaotic exit from the European Union.

By preaching and spreading democracy and freedom to countries like Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya and Syria through active Western military intervention, these countries are today failing and failed states.

As one Singapore comedian puts it, colonisation comes from the word “colon”, out of which bad things come out. The irony is that Britain colonized Hong Kong by giving economic freedoms but not electoral democracy.  And now Hong Kongers are victims of the Stockholm syndrome, where the physically free but mentally captive Hong Konger actually loves the captor country that refuses to grant Hong Kong British National (overseas) passport holders automatic right to UK citizenship.

Democracy and freedom are concepts like beauty in the eye of the beholder. They mean many things to different people, in different contexts.

Countries like Iraq and Afghanistan find that they have the right to vote, but descend quickly to tribal factionalism, religious differences and bad bureaucracies that cannot deliver law and order, personal safety or proper jobs.

They also found out that votes can be bought and sold.   Electoral democracy is essentially a feedback mechanism to tell those in power what the voters don’t like or like, but does not automatically ensure that what is desired is delivered.

What this means is that the real meaning of democracy and freedom is local in practice, and not theoretical ideals that are universal to all. How democracy and freedoms are practiced are the result of complex social contracts negotiated politically at the local level.

If the protests are meant to deliver a message of dissent, the protestors have won. But protesting through violence is a no-win situation, because the more you win, the more you lose.

French political scientist Pierre Rosanvallon has recently written an important book, Good Government: Democracy beyond Elections (Harvard University Press, 2018). Rosanvallon makes the important point that the crisis of representation in Western democracies reveals some deeper discontent – that parliamentary democracy is not delivering good governance and outcomes.

Democracy (rule of people) comes from the Greek city-states that’s in contrast to aristocracy (rule of elites). In reality, Greek cities were ruled by citizens, but most residents were slaves with no rights. Slavery was abolished only in the 19th century and women were only given votes in the 20th century.

So, universal democracy is a very modern concept which Britain practiced, but did not give to her former colonies until very late before their independence.

The result is that different former colonies practiced different forms of democracy, some “guided” as under former Indonesian President Sukarno, and others evolving into permanently elected leaders, e.g. Zimbabwe under Mugabe.

The French political philosopher Montesquieu (1689-1755) idealized representative democracy into a trinity of executive, checked by the legislature and the judiciary. In the 20th century, it became recognized that a free press is the fourth pillar that ensured democratic checks and balances.

But as Professor Rosanvallon shrewdly observed, these ideals morphed in practice from Parliamentary Democracy towards Presidential Democracy, because as society became more urban, globalized and complex, the demands for executive action to solve social problems became more urgent. These gave more and more power to the executive branch, weakening parliament and putting impossible demands on the judiciary to solve political disputes.

It was therefore not surprising that in the face of everyday ineptitude in governance, many opted for strong leaders and bold executive action.

The traditional print media and guardian of social conscience was hollowed out by digital social media, so that they moved out of a “balanced, rational” debate of social issues into factional press that pushed extremist views of “Likes” and “Dislikes”, in which there are no more compromises for moderate views.

Social media became the connector of disaffected people and enabled them to “swarm”.  When one faction deviated into violence “turbo-charged” by their own extreme beliefs of self-sacrifice and martyrdom, the rule of law became the rule of the swarm.

So which form of system do Hongkongers want in practice? Mob democracy?

Those who believe in law and order cannot understand why those professing to protect the rule of law were destroying it, by creating a double standard of “no amnesty for police” but “amnesty for law-breakers”.

The rule of law functions on the principle that the state, via the police, is the only legitimate channel that can take armed action in order to protect law and order.

Until the violence broke out, Hong Kong was widely admired as a beacon of civilized freedom and rule of law. Today’s vivid image is a city controlled by black-shirted gasmasks.

Democracy and freedom begin with self-discipline, recognizing that self-discipline within law and order protects your own rights as well as the rights of others.

No one has the freedom to destroy other people’s rights through violence. Mob democracy is not the rule of law. The time for violence is over. It’s time to decide which democratic system fits Hong Kong.

By removing the masks, Hong Kongers must face up to very tough choices. Negotiating through gas-masks will only end up in tears.

(The views expressed here are entirely personal to the author.)



Enjoyed this story? Share it.


Asia News Network
About the Author: Asia News Network is a regional media alliance comprising 24 media entities.

Eastern Briefings

All you need to know about Asia


Our Eastern Briefings Newsletter presents curated stories from 22 Asian newspapers from South, Southeast and Northeast Asia.

Sign up and stay updated with the latest news.



By providing us with your email address, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.

View Today's Newsletter Here

Aung San Suu Kyi denies genocidal intent on Rohingya

She urges world court to let Myanmar justice system work. Denying that Myanmar had genocidal intent in its treatment of the Rohingya people, its de facto leader Aung San Suu Kyi on Wednesday (Dec 11) urged the International Court of Justice in The Hague to let her country’s justice system run its course. “Can there be genocidal intent on the part of a state that actively investigates, prosecutes and punishes soldiers and officers who are accused of wrongdoing?” she asked at the world court, while presenting her opening statement on the second day of public hearings related to Gambia’s lawsuit alleging that Myanmar had breached the 1948 Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide. Carefully avoiding the word “Rohingya”, Ms Suu Kyi said Gambia has given “an incomplete and misleading factual picture”. She referred in her half-


By The Straits Times
December 12, 2019

Arguments strong enough to convince judges: expert

Myanmar at The Hague for genocide. The arguments presented by the Gambia’s lawyers at the top UN court yesterday were extremely strong and should convince the judges to issue “provisional measures” against Myanmar to stop genocide against the Rohingyas, said a legal expert. If the International Court of Justice (ICJ) issues such an order, Myanmar will be under real pressure as it is a binding one, said the expert. “It was truly convincing the way the lawyers, who are very reputed in their fields, presented their arguments at the top UN court in the Hague,” Ahmed Ziauddin, a genocide researcher based in Brussels, told this correspondent yesterday. “They made it very clear that provisional measures were urgent to protect the Rohingyas, and such measures won’t affect Myanmar as a state.” The ICJ is not a criminal court that can issue an arrest order against any individual. But


By Daily Star
December 11, 2019

Trump warns N Korea could lose ‘everything’ with hostile acts

Clear warning to Kim regime to refrain from provocations such as nuclear and missile tests. WASHINGTON — US President Donald Trump said Sunday that North Korean leader Kim Jong-un could lose “everything” if he acts in a hostile manner, sending a clear warning to the regime to refrain from provocations such as nuclear and missile tests. Trump sent the tweet as the two countries have exchanged heated rhetoric over their stalled negotiations on dismantling Pyongyang’s nuclear weapons program. Earlier Sunday, North Korea said it had conducted an unexplained “very important test” at its Dongchang-ri satellite launching site, prompting speculation of preparations for a new long-range missile test. But the US president also signaled his commitment to continuing diplomacy with Kim, saying the North Korean leader is “too smart” to be rash. “Kim


By The Korea Herald
December 9, 2019

North Korea has not given up hope for nuclear talks with US yet

Kim has mentioned a possibility of a ‘Christmas’ gift. Tensions between the US and North Korea have heightened as the two sides exchanged threats and bellicose rhetoric of possible military actions if necessary, amid their stalled nuclear talks. But they appear to have no intention to wind up their diplomacy at least for the next few weeks, experts said. On Wednesday, Heino Klinck, US deputy assistant secretary of defense for East Asia, said the US has been refraining from responding to every single one of North On Wednesday, US Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for East Asia Heino Klinck said the


By The Korea Herald
December 6, 2019

Pyongyang to hold party meeting ahead of year-end deadline

Kim Jong-un rides up Paektusan again, highlights self-reliance and revolutionary spirit. North Korea will hold a plenary meeting around the end of December to decide on “crucial issues,” its state-run news agency said Wednesday. On the same day, the Korean Central News Agency reported that North Korean leader Kim Jong-un rode up Paektusan on a white horse accompanied by military commanders, raising speculation that the communist regime may take more provocative military actions as the year-end deadline it set for denuclearization talks with the US quickly approaches. North Korea’s Workers’ Party of Korea announced Tuesday that the 5th Plenary Meeting of the 7th Central Committee of the WPK would convene around the end of December, Korea Central News Agency reported, “in order to discuss and decide on crucial issues in line with the needs of the development of the Korean revolution and the chan


By The Korea Herald
December 5, 2019

Typhoon Tisoy touches down in the Philippines

The typhoon may affect the Southeast Asian games which is currently underway. Typhoon Tisoy slightly weakened early Tuesday morning as it bears down on Burias Island but it remains strong and destructive, the weather bureau reported. In its 5 a.m. Severe Weather Bulletin, the Philippine Atmospheric, Geophysical and Astronomical Services Administration said that Tisoy’s eyewall is currently bringing violent winds and intense rainfall over Camarines Norte, Camarines Sur, Albay, and Masbate. Its eyewall is also expected to affect Southern Quezon, Romblon, and Marinduque in the next three hours. Frequent to continuous heavy to intense (with isolated torrential) rains will be experienced in the Bicol Region, Romblon, Marinduque, Mindoro Provinces, Calabarzon, Metro Manila, Bataan, Pampanga and Bulacan between Tuesday early morning and late afternoon, Pagasa said. Occasional to frequent heavy


By Philippine Daily Inquirer
December 3, 2019