See More on Facebook


OPINION: India 2020: the endgame begins

With the government turning its citizens against each other, the world’s largest democracy is fast losing its legitimacy as a secular republic.

Written by

Updated: February 3, 2020

Indians protesting against the draconian Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA)—which essentially disenfranchises minorities, especially Muslims—were on Thursday, 30 January, faced with a new reality when a 17-year-old shot at peaceful protesters, injuring one, near Jamia Millia Islamia in New Delhi. Even as they commemorated 72 years of the assassination of Mahatma Gandhi that very day, they wondered if the juvenile delinquent shouting ‘the game is over’ for azaadi seekers might as well be a contemporary avatar of Nathuram Godse.

Only that the delinquent this time around was given a free hand by policemen who stood still, their arms folded. And as expected, right-wing television anchors falsely projected the shooter as a protester while he was, in fact, a right-wing zealot with a fetish for Lord Ram, weapons and ‘Hindu rashtra’.

As if on cue, a man on Saturday fired bullets in the air, shouting ‘only Hindus will have their way in India’, near the anti-CAA protest site at Shaheen Bagh in New Delhi. Police were quick to claim he was ‘self-radicalised’ by watching news and videos on social media, ensuring no link with the ruling BJP, if any, was exposed.

The gun-wielders have turned heroes overnight for Hindutva supporters who have bought Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s narrative that ‘Hindus are in danger’. But what is really in danger are the ideals of secularism, democracy and the constitutions Indians of the previous generations valiantly fought for.

The recent gun incidents came on the heels of the BJP-led government’s minister of state for finance Anurag Thakur exhorting people to ‘shoot the traitors of the country’ at a rally while campaigning for Delhi elections; home minister Amit Shah asking voters to choose between Modi and Shaheen Bagh; Uttar Pradesh chief minister Adityanath claiming ‘those who support terrorists in Kashmir are protesting at Shaheen Bagh’; and Prime Minister Modi himself asking people to ‘identify’ anti-CAA protesters by their clothes, indirectly referring to Muslims.

After Saturday’s incident, a Delhi-based friend texted me, ‘I was at Shaheen Bagh jab goli chali’ (I was at Shaheen Bagh when the firing happened). No mention of shock or surprise, as if it was just a daily occurrence. Why, I asked myself, was my friend not shocked when someone opened fire right next to her? Because this was a long time coming. Each new iteration of violence in India today is just a reflection of an irreparably polarised society.

The Right-wing Hindutva leaders may consider taking a break now that their relentless effort at communalising the Indian public has now come to fruition. The making of a ‘self-radicalised, lone wolf’ Hindutva fanatic has been completed. Once the project of projecting minorities as monsters take shape, it is the majority who do the discriminatory state’s bidding. Earlier, you needed the killing of a cow, or at least the rumour of the killing of a cow, for the Hindutva lynch mob to turn against a fellow human being. Now, all you need is the chanting of the ‘azadi’ slogan for a lynch mob to come charging at you with clubs or lone wolves brandishing a gun.

From lynch mobs maiming and killing one individual with a lathi to one individual wielding a gun to terrorise thousands of peaceful protesters, the march towards turning Indians against one another has turned one notch sophisticated.

For the uninitiated and the ones with fading memory, India has remained the hotbed of communalism ever since—and of course even before—it came into existence in 1947. From Gujarat to Delhi, Kashmir to Muzaffarnagar, the fire of communalism, often stoked by state functionaries, politicians and communal leaders, has engulfed India almost every decade. But the extent to which state machineries and media are used to silence citizens in the past six years, after Narendra Modi’s ascent to power, was unprecedented.

In today’s India, it is a crime to be a student, an activist, an inquisitive citizen or a sensible human being because they discuss and ask difficult questions on rising unemployment, downward spiral of the economy, and growing instances of violence. Children aged as young as nine are interrogated for performing a play critical of the CAA, their parents and teachers being accused of sedition.

To be Muslim seems to be the biggest of all crimes. It is, therefore, not at all surprising that the machinery of the state in tandem with the media have been used to punish, vilify and threaten those who ask questions and dare to puncture the narrative of a monolithic nation.

In a span of a few years, the image of a Muslim individual has been turned into that of an outsider and a potential threat to the ideals of a ‘Hindu’ India. From Mohammad Akhlaq to Pehlu Khan, Mohammad Qasim to Tabrez Ansari, the image of a Muslim individual is that of a helpless individual begging for life, hands folded into a ‘namaste’, in front of soon-to-be executioners before being beaten to a pulp and turned into a corpse not long after.

Having witnessed, often silently, the undignified deaths of fellow citizens for far too long, Indians today have lost a sense of human dignity themselves. A society in which an individual or a community is stripped of human dignity and rendered the ‘other’ is moribund. With citizens being manipulated into coming to blows against one another, India has lost its credentials as a secular democracy and a tolerant society.

As India’s friendliest neighbour, and the most susceptible to the Hindutva frenzy, we in Nepal have a lot to be cautious about.

Enjoyed this story? Share it.

The Kathmandu Post
About the Author: The Kathmandu Post was Nepal’s first privately owned English broadsheet daily and is currently the country's leading English-language newspaper.

Eastern Briefings

All you need to know about Asia

Our Eastern Briefings Newsletter presents curated stories from 22 Asian newspapers from South, Southeast and Northeast Asia.

Sign up and stay updated with the latest news.

By providing us with your email address, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.

View Today's Newsletter Here


EDITORIAL: Mr Trump in India

US President and Prime Minister Narendra Modi were able to convey a robust message to the west of the Radcliffe Line, thanks largely to their personal chemistry. The diplomatic irony has been rather exceptionally bitter. Donald Trump’s 36-hour visit to India was somewhat pushed out of focus by the communal flare-up that has overwhelmed parts of Delhi, with the death toll rising to 27 till Thursday afternoon. And yet the US President and Prime Minister Narendra Modi were able to convey a robust message to the west of the Radcliffe Line, thanks largely to their personal chemistry. And unlike some previous US Presidents, Mr Trump chose not to follow up his visit to India with another to Pakistan… as often as not to sing a different piece. No, he hasn

By The Statesman
February 28, 2020


As Covid-19 spreads, public health officials consider plans for a worst-case scenario

 Department of Health Services has a Plan B for a few infections but its Plan C envisions shutting down all schools, public transport and gatherings in case of a mass outbreak. While Covid-19 coronavirus infections have significantly slowed in China, they are rapidly spreading around the globe, prompting countries to step up measures to control the spread and the UN 

By The Kathmandu Post
February 28, 2020


Vietnam reaffirms support for nuclear non-proliferation treaty

Ambassador Dang Dinh Quy, head of Vietnam’s Permanent Mission to the United Nations, has reaffirmed Vietnam’s strong support for the realisation of the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons (NPT) on three pillars. During a session of the United Nations Security Council (UNSC) in New York on the occasion of the 50th anniversary of the NPT, Ambassador Quy affirmed that Vietnam has joined all international efforts regarding non-proliferation of nuclear weapons, including regional and global conventions; complied with the International Atomic Energy Agency’s highest safety standards; and strictly followed the UNSC’s resolutions. He said any intentional, unintentional or miscalculated use of nuclear weapons seriously threatened global peace and

By Viet Nam News
February 28, 2020


Budget debate: Coronavirus concerns present long-term opportunities, say MPs

Many have little savings to see them though a work drought, she said, noting that a number of events and work assignments have been cancelled or deferred as a result of the Covid-19 outbreak. While the coronavirus outbreak has battered businesses, it has also created opportunities to better prepare Singapore for future challenges, MPs said on Thursday (Feb 27). Speaking on Day 2 of the debate on the Budget statement, they said these include getting more firms to adopt e-commerce, diversifying supply sources and making flexible work arrangements permanent for working parents and caregivers. A total of 54 MPs, including political office holders, spoke over two days on various aspects of the Budget. USING TODAY’S CRISIS TO PREPARE FOR THE FUTU

By The Straits Times
February 28, 2020


Coronavirus: 2 new cases confirmed; 4 more, including private hospital doctor, discharged

 Two patients from the Grace Assembly of God cluster, cases 49 and 73, were also discharged.  Two new cases of the coronavirus disease (Covid-19) were confirmed by the Ministry of Health (MOH) on Wednesday (Feb 26) and four others have recovered and were discharged. This brings the total number of cases here to 93, of which 62 have fully recovered. Case 59, the private hospital doctor, was among the four discharged. The 61-year-old Singaporean was confirmed to have the virus on Feb 13 and had been warded at the National Centre for Infectious Diseases. He is not linked to any of the five known clusters but is a non-medical contact of case 72, a 40-year-old man from China who holds a Singapore work pass. Case 56, a Banglad

By The Straits Times
February 27, 2020


Japan provides protective gear for use in battling coronavirus

 The government of Japan has given personal protective supplies to the Ministry of Health to help medical staff if they are required to care for people infected with the coronavirus. The items were handed over at the Ministry of Health on Tuesday by the Ambassador of Japan to Laos, Mr Takewaka Keizo, to Minister of Health Assoc. Prof. Dr Bounkong Syhavong. The supplies comprised 4,680 isolation gowns, 6,100 gloves, 6,000 N95 masks, 13,200 surgical masks, 27 goggles, and 240 bottles of alcohol hand rub. Assoc. Prof. Dr Bounkong thanked the government of Japan for its assistance, saying “On behalf of Laos, we would like to express our appreciation to the government of Japan for its continuing support to our country.” The ministry has been st

By Vientiane Times
February 27, 2020