See More on Facebook

News

OPINION: Can Pakistan’s mountain communities protect themselves against melting glaciers?

Climate change is triggering glacial melt in Pakistan and resulting in glacial lake outburst floods.


Written by

Updated: February 10, 2020

A middle aged Shah Raees stands atop the rubble in Barikan Kot village in Bagrot valley of Gilgit Baltistan, as he shares a heart-wrenching story of how his ancestral home and a 10-kanal land in Barikan Kot village was swept away by a historic super flood.

The flood occurred as the iced wall of Hinarchi Glacier, which was holding a big glacial lake had burst, leading to a flood disaster. Raees’s forefathers weren’t the only affectees, as a 100 other households of the village were devastated as well. All of them had to migrate to other areas in search of livelihoods and safety.

But the catastrophe that struck Barikan Kot village more than a century ago is still being felt; the rubble and boulders that came along with the historic super flood are still there. What lies underneath are peoples’ homes, fertile land and orchards. Silence prevails in the area as the land is uninhabitable. Barikan Kot village lays abandoned and deserted.

This situation, however, is not due to just one natural calamity that occurred about a century ago — Barikan Kot village suffers from many glacial lake outburst floods every year. This occurrence of an extreme weather event after a few decades was considered a natural phenomenon, but an unprecedented increase in the intensity and frequency of natural disasters is an anomaly.

Experts call this climate change.

Rising temperatures cause melting glaciers

Temperature rise seems to be the primary cause of glacier melting, including the Hinarchi Glacier on which many glacial lakes are being formed, posing a serious threat to human lives and livelihoods.

Aisha Khan, the executive director of Civil Society Coalition for Climate Change (CSCCC), who also heads the Mountain and Glacier Protection Organization (MGPO), explains why there is an increase in the formation of glacial lakes.

According to her, “global warming and changes in mountain ecosystem will increase the formation of glacial lakes and exert pressure on human and natural systems. Most of these glacial lakes in the Hindu Kush Himalayan region of Pakistan were formed in the last five decades and the number of glacial lake outburst flood events is likely to increase, as new lakes are being formed and old lakes become more unstable”.

Raees says glaciers in Bagrot valley are getting even more unstable and threatening people’s lives. “This year, there was a record glacial lake outburst flood event and our considerable land was inundated due to it. Due to glacier outburst events, the local population and livestock are in danger,” he says.

“The glaciers are slowly moving and have even reached a mosque, which my father had built in the village. As far as I know, due to these glacial outburst incidents, five people have died and over 100 animals have been killed.”

‘Hinarchi Glacier a constant threat’

Global warming poses an existential threat to the glaciers of Pakistan, where it is not just leading to their gradual decline but also resulting in devastating floods. The government has initiated projects to prevent the loss of lives and livelihoods but it needs to step up its efforts to protect the local communities and prevent the glaciers from increased melting.

Syed Zahid Hussain Shah, an expert who manages the threats posed by glaciers, explains this phenomenon as he hikes to the Hinarchi Glacier. According to him, the glacier used to be 18km in length but owing to the impacts of climate change over the past 30 years, it has reduced by approximately 2km. While pointing to the boundaries of Hinarchi Glacier, Zahid says, “Hinarchi also used to have a greater height in the past but due to climate change, it has reduced significantly”.

“The adverse impacts of climate change on the Hinarchi Glacier include the formation of lakes. The depressions on the glacier lead to the formation of glacial lakes every year.

“If these lakes drain, they pose no threat but if they don’t, their chances to burst are high and eventually devastate the downstream communities.”

Zahid was also the field manager of Glacial Lake Outburst Flood-I (GLOF-I) project (2011-2016) jointly managed by the Government of Pakistan and United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) Pakistan. The project aimed to reduce the threat of glacial lake outburst flood incidents in Bagrot valley in Gilgit-Baltistan and Bindo Gol valley in Chitral district of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province.

“The first village to be affected in case of an outburst from Hinarchi Glacier is Chirah, followed by Bulchi. These glacial floods threaten the downstream communities, and frequently damage the water channels, powerhouses and bridges, etc,” says Zahid, adding these glacial lake outburst flood incidents have triggered migration in the valley.

“The increasing number of glacial lake outburst floods from Hinarchi has forced approximately 15-20 households from Chirah village and Bulchi village to migrate to safer places.”

Saving lives through local interventions

Alongside Hinarchi Glacier, Bagrot valley is home to Burche Glacier, Yune Glacier and Gutumi Glacier — and all of them experience outburst floods in July and August, inundating Barikan Kot village and other parts of Bagrot valley.

To reduce the threats posed by glacial lakes, the GLOF-I project took several initiatives in Bagrot valley, including the construction of a bridge and protective walls, and excavation of streams among others. One of the interventions of the project was the installation of four automatic weather stations, meant to relay important information on possible glacial lake outburst flood events to the meteorological department of Pakistan, which could be subsequently shared with the local communities.

“These weather stations proved instrumental in saving many lives in 2014, as it relayed early warning messages of a possible glacial lake outburst flood to the local communities almost 90 minutes before the disaster. This gave enough time to the people to move to safer places before the flood actually came,” says Zahid.

A resident of Bulchi village, Hussain Ali, 50, also feels that these early warning systems helped save human lives. “The early warning systems provided through the project shared accurate information about the upcoming floods, allowing people to shift to safer places.”

Speaking about the devastating impacts of glacial lake outburst floods on the lives and livelihoods of the local communities, Hussain says, “So far, these floods caused by the outburst of glacial lakes have killed more than 20 people and 200 livestock in Bulchi village.”

Seeing the big picture

Bagrot valley isn’t the only one witnessing extreme weather events. Pakistan is home to more than 7,000 glaciers and over 3,000 glacial lakes have formed owing to the increasing impacts of climate change. Of these, 36 glacial lakes are considered potentially dangerous, which can result in glacial lake outburst floods and possibly affect over seven million people, including women and children, in the mountainous region of Pakistan.

Other countries of the Hindu Kush Himalayan region — Afghanistan, India, Bangladesh, China, Bhutan, Myanmar and Nepal — are also vulnerable to glacial lake floods due to global climate change.

According to Irfan Tariq, director general of the Ministry of Climate Change, the entire Hindu Kush Himalayan mountain range “is a very sensitive ecological system and global warming is destabilising the whole region. It is very difficult to control or limit the impacts of climate change on glaciers”.

With regards to the government’s efforts to tackle these extreme weather events, Irfan says, “Pakistan is witnessing an unprecedented surge in glacier outburst incidents. The government is closely looking at the movement of glaciers and the issue has also been discussed during the first meeting of Prime Minister’s Committee on Climate Change.”

“To address the challenges posed by glacial lake outburst floods, the government has launched the GLOF-II project and we hope that it would be a success,” he adds.

GLOF-II (2017-2021) is a US$ 37 million project by the Government of Pakistan and UNDP Pakistan to reduce the threats of glacial lake outburst floods in the Hindu Kush Himalayan region of Pakistan, which includes the Gilgit Baltistan region and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province. The project will cover 10 districts of Pakistan and benefit 29 million people.

Serious impact of glacial lake outburst floods

The fact that Pakistan is experiencing an increase in the intensity and frequency of glacial lake outburst floods is a worrying sign for many. For Syed Mehr Ali Shah, Pakistan Commissioner for Indus Waters and Joint Secretary, Ministry of Water Resources, “these glacial lake outburst floods can have a serious impact if they occur on a large scale”.

“From the perspective of the Government of Pakistan, we are very much concerned with the bigger glacial lake outburst flood events, with regards to the safety of our existing hydraulic infrastructures, which include Tarbela dam.

“In the near future, as we are proceeding towards constructing the Diamer Bhasha dam, the safety of these structures is very important. We need to protect them from any kind of dam break phenomenon, associated with glacial lake outburst floods.”

Mehr adds that the Diamer Bhasha dam “takes into account the perspective of glacial lake outburst floods. Firstly, a provision has been made in the reservoir to bear any dam break wave that occurs due to such flood and secondly, if the reservoir is filled and such incident occurs, then there is ample provision to safely pass that flood through the spillways”.

“However, there is a bigger threat posed by the glacial lake outburst floods. If any hydraulic infrastructure gets damaged due to it, then it becomes a threat to the water and food security of Pakistan, as these dams regulate water all across the country. By having these safety valves in place, it will not be a problem for the country,” adds Mehr.

“Though the mountainous region of Pakistan faces an imminent threat of glacier outburst floods, the government has so far not marked down the vulnerable areas for disaster risk reduction (DRR). The government has approved the 4th National Flood Protection Plan, which involves studying the impacts of glacial lake outburst floods.

“This will lead to the demarcation of areas vulnerable to glacial lake outburst floods and help prepare emergency action plans.”

Way forward

Keeping in view the vulnerability of local women to glacial lake outburst floods, Aisha Khan urges to include females in evacuation, first aid, and rescue and relief operations. “Young and able-bodied women must be trained at par with men to handle the environmental crisis.”

“The early warning system should give enough response time for evacuation, and evacuation drills should be routinely conducted to familiarise people with the protocols.”

She recommends “any infrastructure that is designed as a protective measure for glacial lake outburst floods must be based on bathymetric studies conducted on a regular basis to track ice wall and thinning process”.

“Communicating the scientific reasons of glacier outburst flood events in simple language with the concerned communities is vital to better acquaint them with the changing climate and mobilising their support, as well as leveraging local knowledge and communication tools into the programme,” adds Aisha.

“The impacts of glacial lake outburst floods are catastrophic and require a combination of scientific and social approach to effectively address them in Pakistan,” she cautioned.

Syed Muhammad Abubakar is an environmental journalist. He tweets @SyedMAbubakar



Enjoyed this story? Share it.


Asia News Network
About the Author: Asia News Network is a regional media alliance comprising 24 media entities.

Eastern Briefings

All you need to know about Asia


Our Eastern Briefings Newsletter presents curated stories from 22 Asian newspapers from South, Southeast and Northeast Asia.

Sign up and stay updated with the latest news.



By providing us with your email address, you agree to our Privacy Policy and Terms of Service.

View Today's Newsletter Here

News

EDITORIAL: Mr Trump in India

US President and Prime Minister Narendra Modi were able to convey a robust message to the west of the Radcliffe Line, thanks largely to their personal chemistry. The diplomatic irony has been rather exceptionally bitter. Donald Trump’s 36-hour visit to India was somewhat pushed out of focus by the communal flare-up that has overwhelmed parts of Delhi, with the death toll rising to 27 till Thursday afternoon. And yet the US President and Prime Minister Narendra Modi were able to convey a robust message to the west of the Radcliffe Line, thanks largely to their personal chemistry. And unlike some previous US Presidents, Mr Trump chose not to follow up his visit to India with another to Pakistan… as often as not to sing a different piece. No, he hasn


By The Statesman
February 28, 2020

News

As Covid-19 spreads, public health officials consider plans for a worst-case scenario

 Department of Health Services has a Plan B for a few infections but its Plan C envisions shutting down all schools, public transport and gatherings in case of a mass outbreak. While Covid-19 coronavirus infections have significantly slowed in China, they are rapidly spreading around the globe, prompting countries to step up measures to control the spread and the UN 


By The Kathmandu Post
February 28, 2020

News

Vietnam reaffirms support for nuclear non-proliferation treaty

Ambassador Dang Dinh Quy, head of Vietnam’s Permanent Mission to the United Nations, has reaffirmed Vietnam’s strong support for the realisation of the Treaty on the Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons (NPT) on three pillars. During a session of the United Nations Security Council (UNSC) in New York on the occasion of the 50th anniversary of the NPT, Ambassador Quy affirmed that Vietnam has joined all international efforts regarding non-proliferation of nuclear weapons, including regional and global conventions; complied with the International Atomic Energy Agency’s highest safety standards; and strictly followed the UNSC’s resolutions. He said any intentional, unintentional or miscalculated use of nuclear weapons seriously threatened global peace and


By Viet Nam News
February 28, 2020

News

Budget debate: Coronavirus concerns present long-term opportunities, say MPs

Many have little savings to see them though a work drought, she said, noting that a number of events and work assignments have been cancelled or deferred as a result of the Covid-19 outbreak. While the coronavirus outbreak has battered businesses, it has also created opportunities to better prepare Singapore for future challenges, MPs said on Thursday (Feb 27). Speaking on Day 2 of the debate on the Budget statement, they said these include getting more firms to adopt e-commerce, diversifying supply sources and making flexible work arrangements permanent for working parents and caregivers. A total of 54 MPs, including political office holders, spoke over two days on various aspects of the Budget. USING TODAY’S CRISIS TO PREPARE FOR THE FUTU


By The Straits Times
February 28, 2020

News

Coronavirus: 2 new cases confirmed; 4 more, including private hospital doctor, discharged

 Two patients from the Grace Assembly of God cluster, cases 49 and 73, were also discharged.  Two new cases of the coronavirus disease (Covid-19) were confirmed by the Ministry of Health (MOH) on Wednesday (Feb 26) and four others have recovered and were discharged. This brings the total number of cases here to 93, of which 62 have fully recovered. Case 59, the private hospital doctor, was among the four discharged. The 61-year-old Singaporean was confirmed to have the virus on Feb 13 and had been warded at the National Centre for Infectious Diseases. He is not linked to any of the five known clusters but is a non-medical contact of case 72, a 40-year-old man from China who holds a Singapore work pass. Case 56, a Banglad


By The Straits Times
February 27, 2020

News

Japan provides protective gear for use in battling coronavirus

 The government of Japan has given personal protective supplies to the Ministry of Health to help medical staff if they are required to care for people infected with the coronavirus. The items were handed over at the Ministry of Health on Tuesday by the Ambassador of Japan to Laos, Mr Takewaka Keizo, to Minister of Health Assoc. Prof. Dr Bounkong Syhavong. The supplies comprised 4,680 isolation gowns, 6,100 gloves, 6,000 N95 masks, 13,200 surgical masks, 27 goggles, and 240 bottles of alcohol hand rub. Assoc. Prof. Dr Bounkong thanked the government of Japan for its assistance, saying “On behalf of Laos, we would like to express our appreciation to the government of Japan for its continuing support to our country.” The ministry has been st


By Vientiane Times
February 27, 2020